A June 3 repost by streamer YourRage comparing Jay Cinco to “Love Island USA” newcomer Sincere Rhea snowballed into a full-blown look-alike debate online—until Jay Cinco responded on Instagram with a joke and a warning: “Man watch out 😂😂😂.”
A single repost on June 3 sent the “Love Island USA” internet into a familiar frenzy: people started asking whether a newcomer might look like someone viewers already know.
Streamer YourRage reposted a photo of Sincere Rhea. the “Love Island USA” newcomer on Season 8. and tagged Jay Cinco—adding fuel to the idea that the two could be related. As comparisons continued to circulate. Jay Cinco eventually reposted the side-by-side chatter to his Instagram Story and pushed back in the only way he knew how to turn it—humor.
On his Instagram Story, Jay Cinco joked, “Man watch out 😂😂😂” before adding, “Why everybody keep tagging me in dis shi 😂.”
The debate didn’t stay quiet. A wave of social media users shared the Shade Room-style side-by-side photo and waded into the comments with split opinions—some seeing a real resemblance, others saying the comparison doesn’t hold up.
Instagram user @secretlifeof_tiara wrote, “Is that his brother !?!” Another user, @blognae.__, said, “Sincere looks way better than Cinco.” @sharksleigher took a lighter approach: “well he is on there getting ready to shark so lmao.”
Others went for tougher comparisons and references—@bighomieduwop wrote, “So that’s not Princeton from Mindless Behavior?” While @_hendrix1 said, “Cut it out that’s Walmart Julian Newman 😂.”
Some commenters claimed they’d confused different celebrities entirely. Instagram user @emmi_scott00 wrote, “Thought that was Austin McBroom for a second.” And @teri.michelle_ was blunt: “they don’t look nothing alike.”
@badinfluence_3 summed up the backlash with: “Definitely not. cinco got him beat to the max 😭😭😭.”
The timing is notable in its own way: “Love Island USA” is only just getting started with Season 8. The first episode premiered on Tuesday, June 2, and even before viewers fully settle into this year’s villa dynamics, the cast is already producing conversation that spills well beyond the screen.
Season 8 has also sparked headlines for reasons that are less about looks and more about off-camera fallout. Sean Reifel’s mother spoke out after the mayor of Sean’s Pennsylvania hometown criticized the former police officer for leaving his law enforcement career to appear on the reality dating series. In her statement. she claimed officials “missed a huge opportunity to make a positive impact” and said the mayor did not “tell the whole story” regarding Sean’s background. training. and leave request before joining the show.
At the same time, Vasana Montgomery broke her silence after being removed from the show. She apologized for using a racial slur in resurfaced videos that circulated online after the Season 8 cast reveal.
With new episodes still ahead, the Sincere Rhea-and-Jay Cinco look-alike debate is one of the latest ways Season 8 has quickly turned into a two-track story: romance competition on-screen, internet argument off-screen.
And now, at least for Jay Cinco, the message is clear—even if the memes are just starting: “Why everybody keep tagging me in dis shi 😂.”
Jay Cinco Sincere Rhea Love Island USA Season 8 YourRage Instagram Story look-alike debate social media reactions Sean Reifel Vasana Montgomery Shade Room