Connor Storrie’s – In Season 4, Episode 4 of “Criminal Minds: Evolution,” Connor Storrie appears as Lance—the stalker ex-boyfriend the BAU initially suspects as the Fan—before a harrowing test exposes the mix-up. The episode leans hard on Storrie’s ability to land ambiguity: a t
When Connor Storrie steps into “Criminal Minds: Evolution” for Season 4, Episode 4, it isn’t the usual kind of guest appearance. He arrives as Lance, a stalker ex-boyfriend, and he does it with a kind of controlled danger—enough to make the BAU’s suspicions snap into place fast.
The Fan is already firmly on the BAU’s radar in Episode 4. and the pressure escalates through a trail of photographs sent to the bureau. That stream of images leads them to Lance, the ex-boyfriend of the woman shown in the photos. At first glance. Lance fits: he carries the same obsessive qualities the Fan would be expected to have. and he’s sharp enough to maneuver around J.J. (A.J. Cook) when she questions him—giving very little away while still sounding convincing.
Then the episode pivots. Lewis (Aisha Tyler) runs a test with a leaky pen. and the results tell the team something crucial: Lance doesn’t have the same level of obsessive compulsion as the Fan. The writing of the unsub—whatever it is behind the stalking—would not allow certain mistakes. In other words. if Lance were the Fan. the behavior wouldn’t hold up under the kind of precision the real unsub is shown to have.
That’s where Storrie’s performance becomes more than just a standout guest role. The character teeters on ambiguity—Lance delivers enough sharpness that the team can suspect him as the unsub. but he also has emotional volatility bubbling beneath the surface that makes the theory harder to settle. It’s the first time the Fan makes a substantial play against the BAU by using Lance like a Trojan horse to get access to the team’s “bag of tricks.”.
And the impact lands. This is also the first time the team has been this rattled in a long time. The Fan, rather than letting the bureau pigeonhole him into a copycat profile, pushes back—taunting Voit (Zach Gilford)—while Lance stays tangled in the larger storyline around the elusive Fan.
Storrie’s range is on full display in the way the episode shifts his emotional register. There’s a borderline homicidal glint in his eyes at times. paired with a deadpan face as Lance genuinely believes he’s doing nothing wrong by stalking his ex-girlfriend. But the episode saves its strongest moment for when Lance faces off against Alvez (Adam Rodriguez).
Alvez doesn’t just threaten him—he manipulates him into putting an end to his extracurricular activities. He does it with a blend of intimidation and psychological pressure, using Lance’s abandonment issues against him. That’s when Storrie changes from furious and offended to something subdued and haunted. The performance lands like a living contradiction: a man who looks dangerous. then suddenly feels breakable. and the transition is unsettling to watch. The episode’s emotional texture even recalls the latter episodes of “Heated Rivalry. ” where Storrie delivered raw performances. but in “Criminal Minds. ” Lance feels less like a person acting out a plan and more like a rabid animal that’s been broken in by Alvez.
If audiences fell for Storrie’s Ilya in the rink through “Heated Rivalry. ” “Criminal Minds: Evolution” offers another angle on the actor—one that signals his stardom won’t be boxed into a single type. In Lance. he flexes emotionally. but he also proves he can switch his emotions in a split second. especially when he’s sharing the screen with Rodriguez.
By the time Episode 4 ends. the takeaway is clear: Storrie’s brief time in the series becomes a major turning point—not just because Lance is memorable. but because the Fan’s move. the BAU’s suspicion. and the chilling uncertainty around who’s really behind the photos all hinge on what Storrie brings to the role.
Connor Storrie Criminal Minds: Evolution Season 4 Episode 4 Lance Fan BAU A.J. Cook Aisha Tyler Adam Rodriguez Alvez Zach Gilford Voit J.J. stalker ex-boyfriend