Riverdale star KJ Apa and viral music persona Mr. Fantasy were allegedly seen together in West Hollywood on Friday, May 23—adding fuel to an identity mystery that KJ himself addressed after the release of Mr. Fantasy’s “Do Me Right” video.
KJ Apa has been denying — loudly, and then in his own way — that he and Mr. Fantasy are the same person. So when footage started circulating showing both together for dinner in West Hollywood. the question fans can’t stop asking turned from “Is he or isn’t he?” to a more unsettling “What’s really going on?”.
Mr. Fantasy began taking over social media last year, and his profile got even bigger after he appeared in the 2025 Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. That boost only intensified rumors that the viral star might be KJ Apa in disguise.
Those suspicions grew even stronger because KJ and Mr. Fantasy are reportedly covered in the exact same tattoos, and their faces are described as practically identical. Fans have suggested KJ has been wearing a wig and fake teeth for the “alter-ego.”
But the latest sightings complicate the story. Mr. Fantasy and KJ Apa were allegedly spotted together on Friday. May 23. with TikTok user @angelaryan03 posting a video that appears to show the two having dinner at the restaurant Great White in West Hollywood. California. DeuxMoi also shared a photo of the sighting.
The reactions online split in a familiar way—some treated it like a wink at the mystery, others treated it like a problem. One fan commented, “That IS KJ but that is NOT Mr. Fantasy.” Another wrote, “I love how far he’s willing to go for the bit.”
KJ’s own frustration has already entered the equation. Just recently, after the release of Mr. Fantasy’s “Do Me Right” music video—which includes cameos from many of the actor’s friends—KJ called out Mr. Fantasy. “Enough is enough. I won’t sit back any longer and watch someone attempt to ruin my life and everything I have worked for. ” KJ said.
And that’s where the newest clip hits hardest: if KJ is telling people someone else is trying to take from him. then the internet immediately starts searching for what the dining-room footage would mean. Fans are now speculating that someone else may be dressed up as Mr. Fantasy—creating this viral moment while KJ continues to insist he’s not playing both roles.
As the identity rumors spiral again, the most immediate takeaway is simple: the story KJ tried to shut down now has fresh visuals attached to it, and the internet isn’t letting go.
KJ Apa Mr Fantasy Riverdale viral music star Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade 2025 “Do Me Right” Great White West Hollywood TikTok @angelaryan03 DeuxMoi