Molly Shannon returned to Saturday Night Live on Saturday (May 16) with a surprise cameo that revisited a resurrected sketch—playing a choir teacher who dismisses claims she’s “too handsy,” then escalates the moment with increasingly explicit touches while stu
Molly Shannon didn’t just step into Saturday Night Live—she jumped straight into a sketch that was already built to rattle expectations.. On Saturday (May 16). the 61-year-old actress and comedian returned to the late-night stage for a surprise cameo. repeating her familiar connection to the show that launched her breakout as a cast member from 1995 to 2001.
This wasn’t her first stop back recently.. She last appeared during the 50th anniversary special, and prior to that, she hosted in 2023.. In this week’s episode. she reunited with former co-star Will Ferrell in a sketch centered on high school students who are waiting for their upcoming musical’s cast list to be posted.
The setup leads to “Cast List 2. ” where Shannon appears closer to the end—playing the school’s (handsy) choir teacher and the show’s music director. Ms Peebles.. In her on-camera pitch, her character directly tackles the label she’s been given.. “A couple of things about me,” she says.. “First of all, some people say that I’m too handsy with boys.. That’s a lie.. I don’t know who started it.. And number two, I am tough as nails, but guess what?. I get results.”
Then comes the moment the sketch clearly wants to push further.. Shannon says. “Watch this. ” and calls over a student named Tommy Brennan. asking him to sing the highest note he can.. After he complies. she tells him he can do better. instructs him to pull his tummy in. and touches his stomach. saying he has nice abs.. She then tells him to put his butt out. yanks up his pants as he sings higher. before she reaches from behind and grabs his crotch with both hands.
The sketch adds another layer by pointing backward, not just forward. It was one resurrected from a sketch that was cut for timing during Will Ferrell’s hosting gig back in 2019.
The thread running through the episode is simple: Shannon’s cameo is framed as a reunion for a “cast list” sketch with Will Ferrell. and within that setup. “Cast List 2” resurrects a previously cut bit—so the show can bring Ms Peebles back to the screen and stage the “too handsy” denial alongside the escalating physical comedy.
For viewers who want the full context, the sketch runs about 7.5 minutes, and the full segment is available to watch in the embedded video linked with the report.
Molly Shannon Saturday Night Live SNL Will Ferrell May 16 cameo Ms Peebles Cast List 2 Tommy Brennan choir teacher sketch 7.5 minute sketch