Joey Graziadei shared that he proposed to his fiancée Kelsey Anderson for the second time, writing that “She Said Yes (again)” and explaining why he wanted to reaffirm their promise.
Joey Graziadei didn’t just plan for a wedding milestone—he marked it twice.
The 31-year-old The Bachelor star took to Instagram on Tuesday, May 26, to share that he got down on one knee for a second proposal to his fiancée, Kelsey Anderson. In the caption, Graziadei opened with the simple line: “SHE SAID YES (again).”
He also explained what drove him to make the moment happen again. “Proposing again meant taking something that was already extraordinary and making it fully our own. It means the world to be able to reaffirm our promise and love to one another just the two of us. Forever isn’t enough with you. I cannot wait to make you my wife,” he wrote in a joint post with Anderson.
The timing of the first proposal matters to the story. Graziadei originally proposed to Anderson on the season finale of The Bachelor season 28. That finale aired in March 2024, after being filmed during the show’s November 2023 finale period.
For the second proposal, the tagged location on the post pointed to Cabo San Lucas, Mexico. Their first proposal also took place in Mexico, but in Tulum—so the couple’s romantic “yes” has already come with a geography lesson.
Even with that history, the pair has previously been open about not rushing into marriage. At the same time, wedding planning is currently well underway.
Earlier this year, Graziadei added to the building anticipation by sharing a fun video on Instagram in which he asked one of his fellow The Bachelorette alums and close friends to be his best man.
Joey Graziadei Kelsey Anderson The Bachelor proposal engagement Cabo San Lucas Tulum Instagram wedding planning best man