Carroll and Arenado headlines MLB DFS picks May 21

Top MLB – With seven MLB games tipping between 1:10 p.m. ET and 9:40 p.m. ET on Thursday, May 21, DFS players are lining up around a familiar burst of momentum: Arizona’s Corbin Carroll brings an eight-game hitting streak into DraftKings ($5,400) and FanDuel ($3,900), w
Thursday’s MLB slate doesn’t just start early—it runs late enough to feel like the weekend’s already underway. There are seven games on the schedule, with first pitch set to begin at 1:10 p.m. ET and the last game slated for 9:40 p.m. ET.
For daily fantasy players, that stretch matters. It’s the difference between building lineups that can survive shifting late-game pitcher matchups and those that get stuck hoping a single at-bat turns into a season saver.
Among the top names in the player pool for MLB DFS on Thursday, May 21 are Spencer Strider, Jose Soriano, Nick Kurtz, Ketel Marte, Matt Olson and Ben Rice—players scheduled to be in action. The bigger pitch, though, is that one lineup can pivot on a hitter who’s swinging the bat like he can’t miss.
One of the featured targets is Arizona outfielder Corbin Carroll, priced at $5,400 on DraftKings and $3,900 on FanDuel. Carroll comes in red hot: he has hits in eight consecutive games. That run includes a 2-for-4 performance with two homers, three RBI and one walk on Sunday. For the season, Carroll is hitting .285 with 11 doubles, six triples, seven homers and 24 RBI in 45 games.
Carroll isn’t being treated as a solo play either. He’s also being stacked with third baseman Nolan Arenado, listed at $3,300 on DraftKings and $3,100 on FanDuel. Arenado has been producing with consistency—he has hit in each of his last three games. That recent stretch includes two doubles in four at-bats in Tuesday’s 5-3 win over San Francisco. and a homer plus four RBI in Monday’s 12-2 win over the Giants. Through 45 games this season. Arenado is hitting .278 with nine doubles. seven homers and 25 RBI. with splits described as resurgent and the highest since 2022.
The lineup-building tension here is simple: Carroll’s form is immediate and loud—eight straight games with hits—while Arenado’s recent outputs are the kind DFS lineups quietly depend on, game after game, to keep points accumulating when the slate stretches from afternoon into night.
A DFS pro with more than $2 million in career winnings has turned his attention to the Thursday action and locked in top daily Fantasy baseball picks. The approach described centers on a prediction model that simulates every minute of every game 10. 000 times. factoring in matchups. statistical trends and injuries. with the goal of finding best MLB DFS values and creating optimal lineups.
And while Carroll and Arenado provide the headline momentum. the day’s slate still leaves room for a single key difference-maker in tournament building. The pick framed as a potential breakout on Thursday is said to be driven by an optimal matchup—positioned as the kind of selection that can separate tournament success from cash-game routine.
Thursday, May 21 starts at 1:10 p.m. ET and runs until the final first pitch at 9:40 p.m. ET. With Carroll’s eight-game hitting streak and Arenado’s recent production shaping two of the most prominent DFS targets on the slate. the question for players gets sharper by the hour: will the momentum carry through the late games—or will the slate’s long window of pitching matchups break the plan?.
MLB DFS DraftKings FanDuel Corbin Carroll Nolan Arenado Spencer Strider Jose Soriano Nick Kurtz Ketel Marte Matt Olson Ben Rice May 21 daily fantasy baseball picks
Eight-game streak already?? I swear baseball players always get hot right when I lose money on DFS.
So is this saying Corbin Carroll is like guaranteed to homer or whatever? Because “eight games in a row” sounds made up lol.
Arenado at $3,300 on DraftKings and $3,100 on FanDuel… am I reading that right? Also the article cuts off mid-sentence with the 5-3 win, so I’m just supposed to guess the rest. DFS articles always do this.
Spencer Strider and Jose Soriano on the same slate?? I thought Soriano was a different guy like the pitcher from years ago, but maybe I’m mixing names. Either way, 1:10pm to 9:40pm is way too long, I can’t even stay awake for that so I’d probably pick whoever’s cheapest.