Gmail caps – Google is testing a Gmail change that starts new users on a 5GB storage limit until they add a phone number to unlock the full 15GB—an approach critics say effectively trades privacy for capacity.
When new Gmail users sign up and see their cloud storage capped at just 5GB, it isn’t exactly a subtle nudge. The full 15GB doesn’t appear automatically—Google is instead testing a setup where users in some regions must add their phone number to unlock the higher storage allowance.
Google has confirmed the test to Android Authority, saying it applies to new users in specific regions and is intended to deliver “a high-quality storage experience.” The company also argues the change pushes users to protect their accounts and improve data recovery.
That explanation, though, hasn’t calmed the anxiety around the mechanics of the trade. The concern is straightforward: the storage cap is already there, and the phone number is the key to getting it back.
Google says the phone number requirement is about recovery. Adding a number, the company suggests, helps users regain access if they’re locked out. Google also points to other recovery options, including adding a second email address or a recovery contact.
But critics question why the unlock is tied to phone-based verification in particular.. Google also highlights passkeys and other authentication methods as more secure than text messages. which it notes are more vulnerable to SIM swap attacks. phishing. and other abuse.. The mismatch—security benefits described on one hand. and a phone number request on the other—has fueled doubts about what’s really being optimized.
There’s also the argument that a phone number gate could deter spammers and scammers who spin up accounts without valid phone verification.. Google’s reasoning fits a familiar pattern: fewer accounts created in bulk without phone verification can mean less cleanup later.. Still. some regions already require a phone number to create a Gmail account at all. and cybercriminals can obtain burner numbers through VoIP services.
Even if the threat model is real, the fallout from a smaller free storage tier may land on legitimate users.. Colleague Rob Triggs has pointed out that this 5GB Gmail cap could also affect Google Drive. raising the risk of serious disruption for people relying on it—especially for things like WhatsApp backups.
Google, for its part, isn’t offering an open-ended bargain.. The company is not simply asking for a phone number and then giving nothing in return.. It says this is a “test. ” and the framing matters: if it stays limited to new users in certain regions. the policy might not become permanent.. But the structure is still hard to ignore.. It withholds two-thirds of the free storage allowance until users share more personal information.
The company also appears to be drawing a line it has used before.. Google offered 2GB of extra cloud storage in earlier years in exchange for completing a security checkup.. In this case. though. the incentive is storage capacity itself rather than a one-time add-on—and critics say that choice makes the exchange feel more like a hook.
Skepticism grows because the testing approach mirrors how other free tiers have tightened over time.. The 5GB cap is described as lining up with the free iCloud Mail tier. while Outlook offers 15GB of free storage and Yahoo Mail provides 15GB or 20GB depending on region.. Critics also point to the broader track record of big tech dialing back free access—citing Google Photos’ shift to a 15GB cap in 2021 and the gradual degradation of free YouTube viewing as moves aimed at driving subscriptions.
For now. there is one detail that eases the sharpest edge of the policy: the test doesn’t appear to apply to existing users who are already under the 5GB cap.. Google also reportedly allows up to four accounts attached to the same phone number. meaning at least some people can manage multiple identities without repeating the phone-number step for each new account.
Still, for new sign-ups in the affected regions, the immediate question remains: would you trade a phone number for storage capacity you expected to receive with your account in the first place?
As the test plays out, the debate isn’t just about storage space.. It’s also about what that space costs—especially when users are asked for personal information at the same time governments and agencies are tightening attention on people. including immigrants and citizens.. In that atmosphere, the “test” label doesn’t fully blunt the discomfort.
Google says its goal is “a high-quality storage experience” and better account recovery.. Critics say the results could feel like dangling the existing cap until users feel compelled to comply.. The only clear certainty right now is that a slice of new Gmail users are being asked to choose between 5GB and a phone number—before they’ve even built their routine in the service.
Gmail storage Google cloud storage phone number requirement account recovery SIM swap attacks passkeys Google Drive storage WhatsApp backups cybersecurity privacy