Have We Passed Peak Populism? Analyzing the Future of Liberalism

David Brooks and Fareed Zakaria analyze whether the populist wave in American politics has reached its end and how liberal democracy can be rebuilt.
The recent political landscape in the United States, defined by the outcome of the 2026 election, has prompted a significant debate regarding the trajectory of global populism. Observers are questioning whether the anti-elite sentiment that fueled political shifts over the last decade has reached a turning point. In a wide-ranging discussion, political commentator David Brooks and author Fareed Zakaria explored whether the Trump era and the broader populist moment are fading, and what framework might be necessary to restore popular legitimacy to liberal democratic institutions.
Brooks, referencing historical patterns, suggested that societies often face periods of crisis when elites become detached from the public, leading to a loss of legitimacy. He proposed that the 2026 American election might signify more than just a rejection of Donald Trump, potentially indicating that the peak of the populist movement has passed. Zakaria, while acknowledging the validity of this assessment, pointed to the deep-seated nature of the backlash against decades of globalization and rapid technological change. He noted that while right-wing populism—often characterized by a politics of nostalgia—may have struggled to provide effective policy solutions, the underlying causes of the dissatisfaction remain unaddressed.
Both commentators analyzed the role of the modern elite in this crisis. Zakaria described the rise of a credentialed, meritocratic class that has become increasingly insular, distancing itself from the broader population. He highlighted how success in this system is often viewed as a result of individual merit, ignoring structural advantages, which has deepened feelings of resentment among those left behind. Brooks admitted to his own past oversights, acknowledging that the establishment, of which he has been a part, failed to recognize the extent of the cultural and economic dislocation felt across large swaths of the country.
To understand the current volatility, Brooks drew on the work of the late political scientist Samuel Huntington, specifically his theory that nations periodically undergo “moral convulsions.” These periods, characterized by a desire to upend existing systems, are often accompanied by technological shifts that fragment social cohesion. According to this framework, the United States is currently navigating a period of rupture, which, while challenging, could lead to a necessary process of repair and renewal.
Technology and its role in fragmenting the American experience also emerged as a central theme. Zakaria observed that the decline of common cultural touchstones—exacerbated by digital fragmentation—has made it difficult to sustain a shared moral order. Where a common script once existed in American life, radical individualism and siloed communication have replaced it, complicating efforts to build a unified national narrative.
Looking forward, both Brooks and Zakaria emphasized the difficulty of re-envisioning a leadership class that is both competent and connected to the public. They argued that current educational and social institutions contribute to a system of segregation, limiting social mobility and stifling diverse leadership. Zakaria noted that while Artificial Intelligence may revolutionize analytical tasks, the future of human leadership must increasingly prioritize qualities such as judgment, courage, and wisdom—traits that cannot be automated.
Ultimately, both agreed that the recovery of liberal democracy requires an evolution beyond the current ideological divisions. While Brooks expressed a cautious optimism that the populist tide is receding, he stressed that rebuilding these systems is a project that will require significant time and introspection. Zakaria concluded that the challenge lies in creating a society that fosters diversity and economic vitality while addressing the anxieties created by rapid change, ensuring that liberal values remain an enduring framework for individual autonomy and dignity.