Lifestyle

Experts Offer Guidance on Sanitizing and Maintaining Kitchen Cutting Boards

From wood to plastic and composite materials, food safety experts explain the best methods for sanitizing cutting boards and maintaining them for longevity.

The cutting board is arguably one of the most frequently used tools in the kitchen, yet it is often the least considered. It routinely handles raw chicken, onions, bread, and other ingredients, often receiving little more than a quick rinse between tasks. While home cooks frequently debate the merits of wood versus plastic, food safety experts suggest the more critical focus should be on how these tools are cleaned and maintained to ensure food safety.

“I think the real question is not which is safer, but are they both safe to use?” said Donald Schaffner, a professor of food science at Rutgers University who studies bacterial movement between surfaces.

For years, plastic was generally viewed as the safer alternative, primarily due to perceptions that it was easier to sanitize. However, research conducted in the 1990s by Dean Cliver, a food safety researcher at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, challenged this assumption. Cliver tested wood boards by applying salmonella and E. coli, finding that the bacteria were drawn into the wood, where they ceased to multiply and eventually died. In contrast, while plastic boards are easy to clean initially, deep knife grooves can trap residues such as chicken fat, making them difficult to sanitize manually.

Schaffner noted that while the research landscape is “a bit muddied,” Cliver’s work demonstrated that wood was not as high-risk as once believed, partly due to the material’s natural antimicrobial properties. Nicole Papantoniou, senior director of the Kitchen & Cooking Lab at the Good Housekeeping Institute, utilizes both materials in her own kitchen.

Beyond traditional wood and plastic, composite boards made from wood or paper fibers bonded with resin have gained popularity. Epicurean, a manufacturer of such boards, claims these materials allow knife cuts to remain open rather than closing over food particles, facilitating easier cleaning. Schaffner acknowledged, however, that independent research comparing composite or bamboo boards to traditional wood and plastic remains limited.

Other materials present different challenges. Rubber boards, while common in commercial restaurant settings, are often not designed for home use. Glass boards are nonporous but are generally not recommended because they are slippery, prone to breakage, and can dull knives. Similarly, while marble and slate surfaces are aesthetically pleasing for serving cheese or charcuterie, they are unsuitable for cutting, as they can damage knives.

Regarding sanitization, Papantoniou noted that for daily tasks, washing with warm, soapy water and air-drying is typically sufficient. However, true sanitization requires an additional step, especially after preparing raw meat or poultry. Schaffner advised that household tap water is rarely hot enough to effectively kill bacteria. He recommends using diluted bleach according to bottle instructions, running the board through a dishwasher on a sanitizing cycle, or carefully pouring boiling water over the cleaned surface. He cautioned that vinegar and hydrogen peroxide are significantly less effective than bleach for this purpose.

Maintenance requirements vary by material. Wood boards require more attention than plastic; they should be hand-washed, as dishwashers or prolonged soaking can cause warping or cracking. To maintain wood, John Boos & Co., a butcher block manufacturer based in Effingham, Illinois, recommends applying food-safe mineral oil once a month, or more frequently with daily use. Lisa Bosio, vice president of group marketing at the company, advises that boards appear dry or lighter in color when they need conditioning. Wood boards should be stored standing on their edges to allow air circulation on both sides.

For persistent stains, such as those from beets or tomatoes, home care analyst Noah Pinsonnault suggests applying 3% hydrogen peroxide for five minutes before rinsing. He noted that peroxide may lighten dark woods like walnut, so testing on a small area is advisable. Odors can often be removed by scrubbing the board with a paste made of baking soda and water.

There is no fixed rule for when a cutting board should be replaced. Schaffner recommends discarding a board when it becomes increasingly difficult to clean visibly. Papantoniou suggests retiring boards that have warped, plastic boards with deep grooves or frayed edges, and wood boards that exhibit cracks or dark spots that could indicate mold.

What's your take on this story? Share your perspective below.Join in

Join the discussion

0

Ethan Walker

Ethan Walker covers lifestyle trends, travel, food, personal interests, and modern living. His articles offer useful ideas and accessible perspectives on the choices, experiences, and cultural shifts influencing everyday life.
Back to top button