World News

French Broadcaster Apologizes After Guests Suggest Chinese Diaspora Are Spies

French public broadcaster Franceinfo has issued an apology following a broadcast in which panellists suggested that the entire Chinese diaspora in France could be working as spies for Beijing. The channel acknowledged that remarks made during the programme Les Informes were shocking and admitted it failed to challenge the comments while the show was on air.

“During last Friday’s edition of Les Informes, remarks were made about the Chinese diaspora that understandably shocked people,” Franceinfo said in a statement. “We apologise for having failed to pick up on that and challenge them on air at the time. We will be even more vigilant in future.” The network also indicated that a formal statement would be presented during a subsequent episode of the show.

image

The controversy began during a segment of the programme focused on a scandal involving former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang. When asked about the potential presence of Chinese spies in France, Marie-Cecile Naves, a research director at the Institut de Relations Internationales et Strategiques, laughed and replied: “The entire diaspora, potentially.”

Another guest, Vincent Crouzet—a commentator who claims to be a former operative for France’s foreign intelligence agency, the DGSE—asserted that “every Chinese citizen or every Chinese person originally from China … continues to be tied to the [Communist] Party and has to report back regularly.” Crouzet further alleged that China utilizes a significant portion of the diaspora as informants through a network of clandestine police stations in France.

image

Following the broadcast, the Chinese embassy in France lodged a formal protest, labeling the “Chinese spies” narrative “completely groundless” and stating it had “seriously hurt the feelings of overseas Chinese and people of Chinese descent in France.” The embassy urged French media to respect the dignity of the community and to take concrete measures to mitigate the impact of the comments.

While Western governments and various groups have frequently alleged that Beijing operates secret overseas police stations to monitor dissidents—an accusation China has consistently denied—there is no public evidence to support the claim that such outposts are used to manage a large network of informants within the diaspora. Neither Naves nor Crouzet immediately responded to requests for comment.

Analysts and anti-racism advocates have described the incident as evidence of a rising acceptance of xenophobic rhetoric in France, exacerbated by geopolitical tensions with Beijing. Sacha Courtial, a China specialist at the Institut Jacques Delors, noted that the lack of pushback from the show’s host, Hadrien Bect, suggested such ideas are increasingly considered acceptable within public discourse. Remi-Kenzo Pages, spokesman for the Association of Anti-Racist and Racialised Journalists, warned that broadcasting such claims could endanger the safety of those perceived as Chinese, citing past harassment and violence against the Asian community during the Covid-19 pandemic.

In June, France’s National Consultative Commission on Human Rights recommended that the country’s broadcast regulator, Arcom, increase its efforts to prevent the dissemination of hateful content. Reflecting on the incident, Courtial emphasized that while counter-espionage remains a legitimate national security interest, individuals should be judged by their actions rather than their national or ethnic origin. “We cease to be European if we do not maintain our values,” Courtial said.

Sophia Mitchell

Sophia Mitchell reports on international affairs, global developments, and major events across regions. She brings readers reliable updates and useful context on the people, decisions, and challenges shaping an interconnected world.
Back to top button