Andrew Scott Shines in ‘Elsinore,’ but Direction Often Falters

In director Simon Stone’s new film “Elsinore,” Andrew Scott stars as the Scottish actor Ian Charleson, capturing a life defined by professional dedication and the encroaching reality of the AIDS crisis in 1989. The film centers on Charleson’s final act: performing as Hamlet at Britain’s National Theatre while receiving treatment at the Royal Free Hospital’s AIDS ward.
Scott’s performance is the film’s anchor, marked by a restraint and internal rigor that allows the audience to witness a complex progression of emotions during moments of extreme vulnerability. One particular scene in a hospital room—where Charleson masks his fear and sorrow with a practiced smile for arriving visitors—serves as a testament to both the actor’s range and Stone’s decision to rely on a direct, lingering close-up.

However, the film often struggles to maintain this standard of subtlety. Stone frequently defaults to conventional dramaturgical choices that detract from the story’s more authentic elements. An overly insistent score by Stefan Gregory and the inclusion of unnecessary, sentimental subplots often distract from the film’s most compelling narrative: the technical, demanding, and grounding daily rituals of an actor fighting to fulfill a career-defining role despite his deteriorating health.
The film excels when it focuses on the practicalities of Charleson’s life, such as his meticulous health routines and the exhaustion of Shakespearean rehearsals. Scenes depicting fight choreography and dialogue memorization illustrate the comfort Charleson found in his craft. Yet, these moments are often interrupted by predictable tropes, including a montage of “Hamlet” soliloquies that feel like a checklist of Shakespearean milestones rather than organic character development.

Characterizations also suffer from a lack of narrative trust. The portrayal of activist and filmmaker Derek Jarman, played by David Dawson, becomes a point of contention. While the film captures the confrontational nature of their relationship, it makes the baffling decision to frame Charleson as successfully convincing Jarman to accept his choice to remain closeted—a characterization that deviates significantly from the well-documented, uncompromising nature of the real-life Jarman.
Furthermore, Stone repeatedly undermines the impact of Scott’s work by relying on external validation. Rather than allowing the audience to independently recognize the quality of the onstage performance, the film repeatedly cuts to reaction shots of tearful audience members, including Charleson’s physician, played by Olivia Colman.

The film is at its strongest when it portrays the dark, lacerating humor of Charleson’s friend group—a dynamic that serves as a form of psychic armor against the constant presence of death. While “Elsinore” contains a performance of immense power, it is frequently hampered by a perceived lack of courage in its storytelling, opting for tidy, processed sentiment over the raw reality that defines the film’s most poignant sequences.