Christian Nationalists Seek Post-MAGA Shift After Midterm Losses
Following Republican midterm losses, Christian nationalist groups are pivoting away from the MAGA movement to advance a more radical, theocratic agenda.
In the wake of recent Republican midterm election losses, a faction of Christian nationalists is moving to position its theocratic, exclusionary vision as a successor to Donald Trump’s “Make America Great Again” movement.
Members of the movement gathered in Irving, Texas, last week for a three-day conference titled “Christ is King: America After Trump.” The event, which organizers stated drew more than 1,000 attendees, served as a platform to discuss the future of American conservatism. Nick Fuentes, an avowed white nationalist and surprise special guest at the event, characterized the midterm results as a definitive shift in the party’s power structure, suggesting that the election outcomes had effectively dethroned Trump as the movement’s leader.
“This is like the death of Josef Stalin,” Fuentes said during his remarks. “And there is nothing that will fill the void right now.”
Joel Webbon, a 40-year-old pastor and podcaster, organized the conference and served as the master of ceremonies. Webbon leads a movement that advocates for a theocratic government and a patriarchal society. While his ideology remains on the political fringe, Webbon is actively working to expand the influence of Christian nationalism.
Webbon’s vision for the United States includes the establishment of the Apostles’ Creed as the preamble to the U.S. Constitution, the deportation of at least 50 million people, and a societal structure where interracial marriage is considered “not normal.” Furthermore, his stated position is that Jews, Muslims, Hindus, and women should be denied the right to vote or hold public office.
“We can clearly say they have been gaining power,” said Julie Ingersoll, a professor of religious studies at the University of North Florida who has studied Christian nationalism. “I wouldn’t dismiss them.”
Although right-wing Christians have historically been among Trump’s most dedicated supporters—viewing him as a political instrument against cultural opponents—there was palpable dissatisfaction with the former president among attendees at the Irving conference. Some speakers suggested that Trump’s leadership had failed the conservative cause. JP Sears, a right-wing comedian and speaker at the event, questioned if the audience had been “fooled” by Trump, arguing that the former president had become part of the very corruption he once pledged to dismantle.
Webbon presented a four-phase plan to expand the movement’s reach, stating that “phase one is kind of complete” with the Republican election losses. The subsequent phases involve building political machinery, such as door-knockers, phone banks, and donor networks, followed by winning elected office and placing supporters in positions of influence.
“It’s time to get the numbers. It’s time to get the donors. It’s time to get our guys into positions of power,” Webbon said.
While Webbon acknowledged that his political stances are considered unsavory by the broader American public, he and his allies indicated they are holding discussions with individuals considering presidential runs, though they declined to name specific candidates. Webbon characterized the current goal as “breaking containment,” aiming to shift the boundaries of acceptable political discourse over time.
Despite the movement’s growth, its ideology faces scrutiny. Some Republicans, such as Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas, have previously issued warnings regarding rising antisemitism on the political right. Experts like Michael Emerson, a professor of sociology at Rice University, have noted that while Webbon claims to prioritize religion over race, the movement’s core tenets remain aligned with white dominance. The conference itself included vendors selling materials such as Webbon’s book, “White Genocide,” and other items expressing explicitly exclusionary views, which some attendees acknowledged as “edgy.”
Ultimately, Webbon maintains that the current political environment provides an opportunity for his movement to pick up the pieces of the shattered Trumpian coalition and attempt to steer the country toward his vision for a Christian nation.