Federal Judge Denies Administration Effort to Halt Kalshi Lawsuit

A federal judge rejected an emergency request to stop state court proceedings regarding a lawsuit against the prediction market Kalshi.
A federal judge on Friday rejected an attempt by the Trump administration to intervene in a lawsuit brought by New York’s attorney general against the prediction market Kalshi. The decision leaves intact a state-level hearing scheduled for Monday regarding a potential temporary restraining order against the firm.
New York Attorney General Letitia James sued Kalshi in July, alleging the company violates state laws that prohibit wagering on games featuring New York college teams and all sports betting for individuals under the age of 21.
The federal intervention attempt followed a series of developments in the litigation. Earlier on Friday, U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick denied Kalshi’s motion to transfer the New York lawsuit to federal court, determining that prediction markets do not inherently fall outside the jurisdiction of the state. Following that ruling, New York Judge Melissa Crane scheduled a hearing for Monday to consider an application for a temporary restraining order (TRO) that would prevent Kalshi from offering sports contracts without a license from the New York State Gaming Commission.
During an emergency telephone hearing on Friday, Andrew Weisberg, an attorney representing the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)—which regulates Kalshi—asked U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield to block Judge Crane from ruling on the TRO request.
“The temporary restraining order New York seeks would completely shut down Kalshi’s operations nationwide,” Weisberg argued, stating that such an outcome would cause irreparable harm to a regulated market. Kalshi’s counsel, Sean Murphy, had previously warned that the implementation of the TRO would likely necessitate the liquidation of all open positions, causing market disruptions beyond the borders of New York.
Attorneys for the New York attorney general’s office disputed the claims of federal overreach and imminent harm. Kate Rhodes Janofsky, representing the attorney general, argued that the administration failed to provide evidence of irreparable harm or market disruption.
Judge Schofield ultimately denied the federal government’s application, declining to intervene in the state court proceedings.
While the lawsuit filed by the New York attorney general does not explicitly seek to shut down Kalshi, the pending legal challenge could force the prediction platform to fundamentally alter its current operating model if the state’s position is upheld.