Lawsuit Tests Consumer Protection Strategy in Campus Assault Case

A former student who was sexually assaulted at Texas Christian University is pursuing a legal strategy against the school by invoking a consumer protection law from another state.
The lawsuit, filed by a woman identified only as Jane Doe, asserts that the private university in Fort Worth, Texas, violated the Virginia Consumer Protection Act by misleading her about campus safety. The plaintiff is a Virginia resident.
Sexual assault lawsuits against universities are notoriously difficult to win. Such litigation often requires plaintiffs to prove that institutions acted with “deliberate indifference,” according to KC Johnson, a Brooklyn College professor who has tracked lawsuits filed under Title IX of the Civil Rights Act.
Due to these legal hurdles, plaintiffs have attempted various workarounds over the years. Even so, Dr. Johnson characterized a consumer protection claim in this context as “highly unusual,” if not entirely novel.
Legal experts note that if the lawsuit succeeds, it could potentially broaden the legal avenues available to students who find themselves frustrated with the outcomes of their formal complaints against higher education institutions.
In response to the litigation, Texas Christian University has argued that it does not supply “services” within the state of Virginia. Furthermore, the school contended that the woman would not have a complaint against the university had she not attended school in Texas, and it has asked that the case be either dismissed or transferred to Texas.