Business

U.S. Airlines Prioritize Fares Over Full Planes Amid Rising Fuel Costs

U.S. airlines are increasingly willing to fly with empty seats rather than slash fares simply to fill them, betting that disciplined pricing and flight schedules will help protect profits at a time of soaring fuel costs.

By August, United States airfares were up 23.4% over the past year, amid reduced competition following Spirit Airlines’ departure. U.S. airfares rose an average of nearly 23% year-on-year in the seven months through September, far outpacing the 3.6% average increase in overall consumer prices, according to Labor Department data.

image

The strategy has delivered substantial revenue gains as demand has held up despite sharp fare increases. Yet profits have still been squeezed as jet fuel prices surged roughly 90% since the U.S.-Israeli war on Iran began in February, forcing several major carriers to cut earnings forecasts. Gulf Coast spot jet fuel prices have risen from $2.43 a gallon before the war began in February to $4.63 on Oct. 20, according to U.S. Energy Information Administration data.

Executives at Delta Air Lines, United Airlines, American Airlines, Southwest Airlines and Alaska Air Group have emphasized protecting margins over boosting passenger volumes. Across Delta, United, American, Southwest and Alaska, passenger revenue rose nearly $8.8 billion, or 18%, in the third quarter from a year earlier, while passenger traffic increased less than 1%. The divergence shows how much revenue growth now depends on earning more from each passenger rather than carrying more of them. Premium products and changes in passenger mix have also contributed to the gains.

image

Airlines have long balanced fares against how full their planes are, but elevated fuel costs have made executives more willing to sacrifice occupancy and avoid discounts. United’s commercial chief, Andrew Nocella, offered an example during an Oct. 21 earnings call, noting that its leisure load factor fell 1.3 percentage points in the third quarter. While Nocella acknowledged that the decline showed a small amount of elasticity given higher ticket prices, he called it a trade the airline would make every day. American Airlines planes flew less full in the third quarter even as passenger yields jumped more than 18%, and finance chief Devon May told the trade was deliberate. Delta has also been managing the business for margins, according to CEO Ed Bastian.

Still, the Transportation Security Administration screened 2.9% fewer people at U.S. airports in the quarter than a year earlier, raising questions about whether higher fares are beginning to discourage travel. Limited capacity growth and the shutdown of budget carrier Spirit Airlines have also weighed on traffic. Airline executives insisted that demand remains resilient, with Southwest CEO Bob Jordan telling analysts that higher fares are not causing an erosion of volumes after the airline reported a nearly 22% increase in average passenger fares in the first nine months of this year.

image

Carriers are still seeking increases. JetBlue Airways initiated a $10 one-way increase in domestic published fares on Oct. 21, JP Morgan said, following a similar United-led increase the previous week that Southwest subsequently matched. United said it had nothing further to add, while Southwest said it does not publicly discuss pricing. JetBlue did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Delta and Southwest have cut their annual earnings forecasts, while American expects a full-year loss despite sharply higher passenger revenue. Airlines are now scrutinizing expansion plans. American intends to slow growth considerably next year, with May saying the carrier was reassessing whether additional flights would generate enough revenue to cover their operating costs. Southwest has pledged not to pursue growth at the expense of profitability, while United executives have cautioned that airlines’ published 2027 capacity plans may not materialize.

Their resolve faces a test in 2027. Industry schedules point to more flying capacity, potentially intensifying competition for passengers even as fuel prices are expected to stay high and making this year’s substantial fare gains harder to repeat. Six major U.S. airlines plan to grow domestic capacity 3.0% in the fourth quarter from a year earlier and 3.8% in the first quarter of 2027, a sharp acceleration from just 0.2% growth in the third quarter, according to Airlines for America, citing Cirium data.

“If fuel stays elevated, we have to continue to push yield up so that we can make a bit of money,” American Chief Financial Officer Devon May told on Oct. 22. Yield is the revenue airlines collect for each mile passengers fly.

Mia Reynolds

Mia Reynolds covers companies, entrepreneurship, leadership, and changing industries. She turns complex business developments into accessible stories, helping readers follow corporate decisions, market shifts, and trends influencing the global business landscape.
Back to top button