Two Police Officers Dismissed for Lying About Searching for Missing Crash Victims

A misconduct panel has dismissed two Gwent Police officers who failed to search for two missing women following a fatal car accident and subsequently lied about their actions.
A misconduct hearing in South Wales has resulted in the dismissal of two Gwent Police officers who were found to have committed gross misconduct by failing to search for two missing young women involved in a fatal road traffic accident, then providing false accounts of their actions.
PC Richard Hardwick, 32, and PC Lauren Livingstone, 27, were dismissed without notice following a panel conclusion at Rodney Parade in Newport on November 20. The officers were accused of failing to investigate the whereabouts of two women, Eve Smith and Sophie Russon, after their relatives filed missing persons reports on March 4, 2023—the same day the women were involved in a car crash in the St Mellons area of Cardiff.
The accident ultimately claimed the lives of three people, while two others were left with serious injuries. The victims remained trapped in the vehicle for 46 hours before they were discovered. During the disciplinary hearing, the panel determined that both officers had attended the homes of the missing women that evening but failed to conduct the necessary searches, later falsifying records and providing dishonest testimony to supervisors and the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC).
Panel chair Ian Arundale condemned the officers’ behavior as “deliberate and misleading,” noting that it compromised the police investigation. He stated that the officers’ actions carried “high culpability, high harm, and high aggravating factors.” Arundale determined that the officers’ decision to record that searches had been completed, when they had not, formed the basis of an investigation built on false information. Addressing the specific conduct of the officers, the panel chair described Livingstone’s attempt to claim the search documentation was merely “awful” as misleading, concluding that the entry was a deliberate attempt to deceive.
The IOPC, which investigated the case, labeled the officers’ actions as “inexcusable.” Derrick Campbell, the IOPC’s director of engagement, emphasized that Hardwick and Livingstone failed in the most fundamental aspects of policing: integrity and honesty. “PC Hardwick deliberately lied during the course of the missing person investigation, claiming on police records and to his supervisor that searches had been completed,” Campbell said, adding that Hardwick further lied when given the opportunity to provide a truthful account to investigators. Regarding Livingstone, the IOPC noted she had ample opportunity to provide a correct account but chose not to do so, claiming she could not recall the specifics of her home visits.
During the hearing, testimony was heard from family members, including Sophie Russon’s father, Nathan Russon, Eve Smith’s mother, Emma Borg, and Eve’s brother, Zaine Smith. They confirmed the officers visited their homes on the evening of March 4 but stated that no searches of the properties took place. The panel found that while there were some inconsistencies in the families’ testimony, the contradictions within the officers’ statements were significantly more substantial.
Hardwick, who faced six allegations, and Livingstone, who faced four, both sought to mitigate the findings by pointing to previous unblemished records and character references. However, the panel concluded that the gravity of their dishonesty necessitated dismissal, noting that the conduct damaged public trust in policing. The announcement of the dismissals was met with visible relief from the families present.
This case is part of a wider disciplinary process following an extensive investigation by the IOPC. While these two officers have been dismissed, other disciplinary proceedings remain active. Sergeant Matt Jones and former PC Gareth Murphy are scheduled to face their own misconduct hearings, while two additional officers involved in the broader matter have previously been addressed through internal disciplinary meetings.