Sotheby’s Faces $180 Million van Gogh Dispute Over Nazi-Era Provenance

Some of the world’s wealthiest individuals dined on beef and mashed potatoes at Sotheby’s on a Friday evening, where auction house Chief Executive Charles Stewart delivered a rousing speech detailing plans to sell more than $1 billion worth of artwork during the week.
What remained unmentioned to a guest list featuring billionaires Linda Macklowe, Hubert Neumann, and Mitchell Morgan was that the week’s marquee lot—a dreamy 1890 van Gogh landscape titled “Châtaigniers en Fleurs (Blossoming Chestnut Trees)” and valued at around $180 million—was embroiled in a dispute at that exact moment.
Earlier that same day, Jewish heirs of the collector who formerly owned the painting requested that Sotheby’s withdraw the lot from the upcoming Wednesday auction. The heirs asserted that the artwork was sold under duress in 1936 due to Nazi-era persecution.
Legal representatives representing both Sotheby’s and the heirs are scheduled to meet in Manhattan on Monday to discuss a potential settlement.
Industry experts noted that questions regarding the van Gogh’s provenance were already circulating ahead of the sale. However, a public dispute threatens to deter potential buyers concerned about how Sotheby’s allowed a painting with such a troubled history to reach the salesroom.
“It’s a nightmare for Sotheby’s. It’s a nightmare for the owners. It’s a nightmare for the buyers,” said Philip Hoffman, an art adviser and former auction world executive.