World News

Singapore Judge Dismisses Passenger Lawsuit Over Sudden Braking for Chicken

A Singapore district judge has dismissed a negligence lawsuit filed by a passenger against her private-hire driver, following an emergency stop caused by a bird crossing the road. District Judge Jonathan Ng rejected the claim in a decision issued on Wednesday, characterizing the incident as “the vicissitudes of life” and ordering the claimant to pay S$15,000 (US$11,600) in legal costs.

The claimant, Yvonne Chen, sued driver Tan Teng Kiat following an incident on February 19, 2024, along Holland Road. According to the court proceedings, a vehicle traveling in front of them braked suddenly to avoid a bird—identified by Chen as a junglefowl and by Tan as a rooster—prompting Tan to brake hard to avoid a collision. Chen alleged that the driver’s “abrupt and forceful stop” was due to tailgating the vehicle ahead and claimed she was thrown forward in a manner that left her no time to brace for impact.

Tan testified that he was driving at approximately 50km/h and was roughly 10 meters behind the vehicle in front. While Singapore’s highway code suggests a following distance of three car lengths, or 12 to 15 meters, at that speed, Judge Ng determined it was unnecessary to rule on whether the distance was strictly adequate. The judge noted that Tan had managed to avoid hitting the car ahead and that given the suddenness of the event, it was “wholly unrealistic” to expect the driver to have applied a normal brake.

image

“There was nothing more the defendant could reasonably have been expected to do,” Ng wrote, adding that he did not believe the drivers involved had the luxury of time to react differently.

During the proceedings, it was noted that Chen had at least two other pending accident lawsuits before the District Court, in which she was also a passenger. While the judge acknowledged that Chen was an innocent party who sustained injuries, he emphasized that the legal system does not hold individuals responsible for every misfortune others experience.

“In an imperfect world, some losses must lie where they fall,” Ng stated. “This incident, caused as it was by a chicken crossing the road, was unfortunately, but also undoubtedly, part of the vicissitudes of life.”

Free-ranging chickens and native red junglefowl are common in Singapore, with the Ministry of National Development reporting an average of 2,000 public feedback instances annually regarding the birds over the past five years. The fate of the chicken involved in the February incident remains unknown, and Chen has since filed an appeal to the High Court.

Sophia Mitchell

Sophia Mitchell reports on international affairs, global developments, and major events across regions. She brings readers reliable updates and useful context on the people, decisions, and challenges shaping an interconnected world.
Back to top button