Justice Department Moves to Dismiss Alaska Election Certification Lawsuit

The U.S. Department of Justice has asked a federal appeals court to dismiss its ongoing lawsuit challenging the certification of the recent Alaska midterm election, in which Democrat Mary Peltola secured a victory over incumbent Republican Senator Dan Sullivan.
In a brief filed Thursday with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, government attorneys argued that the case is now moot because the election has already concluded. The Justice Department had originally filed the suit in mid-October, requesting that the court block the certification of the Senate results if Senator Sullivan lost, citing concerns that the presence of another candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan on the ballot would create voter confusion.
“The United States therefore reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means of ‘determin[ing] whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant to be cast for Senator Sullivan’ and vindicating the United States’ asserted injury,” the Justice Department stated in the filing. The brief further noted, “There is, accordingly, no need to delve into standing or the merits of the United States’ claims.”

Republicans had previously alleged that the Peltola campaign assisted in recruiting the second candidate named Sullivan to the ballot, an accusation that Peltola has denied. On November 1, a district court judge dismissed the initial case, ruling that federal lawyers lacked the legal standing to pursue the matter. The Justice Department subsequently appealed that decision. The election took place two days after the district court’s dismissal, with Peltola claiming victory after securing over 50% of the first-choice votes, thereby bypassing further rounds of the state’s ranked-choice tabulation process.
In their latest filing, federal lawyers asked the Ninth Circuit to vacate the district court’s November 1 ruling and remand the case for dismissal specifically on the grounds of mootness.
While the legal challenge proceeds, state officials are moving forward with the election process. Carol Beecher, director of the Alaska Division of Elections, has indicated that the state intends to certify the results “as per the law.” Meanwhile, Senator Sullivan has not conceded the race. Following Peltola’s victory announcement, campaign spokesperson Nate Adams stated, “Alaskans deserve a complete and accurate count, and we will let that process run its course until every legal vote is counted and certified.”