Justice Department Moves to Dismiss Alaska Senate Election Lawsuit

The Trump administration moved on Thursday to abandon its lawsuit aimed at blocking the certification of Democrat Mary Peltola’s victory in Alaska’s U.S. Senate race. The administration filed papers with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals requesting that the court declare the case moot, vacate the lower court’s previous dismissal, and remand the matter for final dismissal.
The litigation focused on the appearance of a second candidate on the ballot, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., who shared a name with the incumbent Republican Senator, Dan Sullivan. The Alaska Supreme Court had previously affirmed the legality of the second candidate’s presence on the ballot. Earlier this month, a federal judge in Alaska had already dismissed the administration’s initial lawsuit.
In the latest filing, Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward wrote that the government “reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means of ‘determin[ing] whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant to be cast for Senator Sullivan.'” Attorneys for the state of Alaska, which is under Republican control, had previously argued that the administration’s case was meritless and supported efforts to have it thrown out.
Peltola secured an outright majority in the race, becoming the 56th Democrat in the Senate. She won by a margin larger than the total number of votes received by the second candidate. Following the Justice Department’s move, Peltola issued a statement saying, “Now that the election is over and the voters sent a very clear message about the direction they want our state to go in, I’m eager to move forward and get to work on behalf of all Alaskans.”
The Justice Department initiated the lawsuit at the direction of President Trump, contending that the certification of Peltola’s victory should be halted pending an investigation into voter confusion. The administration did not outline a methodology for conducting such an inquiry given the confidential nature of the ballot. While reports had surfaced alleging that Peltola’s campaign was involved in recruiting the second candidate—a retired schoolteacher from Petersburg—Peltola has denied any involvement, stating she was “not interested in tricking voters.” The candidate himself has maintained he ran independently.
Prior to the election, Republican Governor Mike Dunleavy ordered an investigation into Peltola’s campaign, and the top federal prosecutor in Alaska had described initial reports regarding the candidate recruitment as “troubling.” This move to drop the Alaska case marks the second time since the November 3 election that the Justice Department has acted to dismiss a high-profile legal challenge regarding state election results. Shortly after the election, the department moved to drop a lawsuit that sought to prevent the counting of approximately 20,000 ballots in California, which the administration had alleged belonged to suspected noncitizens, a claim contested by local election officials.