Business

Instagram Head Admits Promoting Safety Tools Without Disclosing Usage

Meta's Instagram chief Adam Mosseri testified that he touted safety features for teenagers without revealing that only a small fraction of users had adopted them.

Adam Mosseri, the head of Instagram at Meta, admitted in a California court on Wednesday that he promoted safety tools for teenagers without disclosing that the features had seen minimal adoption during early testing.

The testimony occurred during the second week of a trial involving a coalition of 29 US states, which alleges that Meta deliberately designed its products to hook children while misleading the public about safety protections. The trial, which began last week, is expected to continue through September.

Jason Slothouber, a lawyer representing the Colorado attorney general’s office, questioned Mosseri regarding two specific safety features: “Take a Break,” launched in 2021, and “Quiet Mode,” released in 2023. Internal company documents presented to jurors revealed that “Take a Break” achieved an adoption rate of 1.8 percent, while “Quiet Mode” saw 8.7 percent usage.

In December 2021, Mosseri testified before Congress about social media’s impact on youth. The day prior, he authored a blog post about the rollout of new safety features, stating that “more than 90 per cent” of teens who set the reminders kept them active. During Wednesday’s court proceedings, Mosseri acknowledged that this figure referred to retention rather than the number of users who adopted the tools.

When asked why the company did not disclose the low initial adoption, Mosseri admitted that Meta had not released those figures. He defended the company by stating that the features were later enabled by default for “Teen Accounts,” which were introduced in 2024 and include parental controls. However, Mosseri was unable to recall if the company had ever disclosed the percentage of teen accounts that have those parental controls enabled.

The court also heard testimony from former employees who characterized the tools as ineffective. Arturo Bejar, a former engineering director at Meta, testified last week that “Take a Break” was “designed to fail.” George Volichenko, a data scientist who worked on Instagram safety features in 2022 and 2023, stated that adoption rates were “very low and disappointing.” Volichenko further testified that Meta’s leadership was uninterested in boosting adoption because turning the features on by default would have had a “notable negative impact” on user engagement.

Francesco Fogu, Meta’s director of product design at Instagram, acknowledged under questioning that the company knew adoption would be lower without default settings. Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers, who is overseeing the case, expressed surprise that Fogu was unaware of the internal data.

If convicted, Meta faces potential penalties of approximately US$200 billion. The legal outcome could force significant changes to the company’s business model and influence broader industry practices regarding teenage safety.

Mia Reynolds

Mia Reynolds covers companies, entrepreneurship, leadership, and changing industries. She turns complex business developments into accessible stories, helping readers follow corporate decisions, market shifts, and trends influencing the global business landscape.
Back to top button