World News

Indonesia’s Forest Protection Pledge Draws Praise and Skepticism

Indonesia’s commitment to halt the conversion of primary forests for food production has drawn international acclaim, including from actor and environmental activist Leonardo DiCaprio, even as forestry experts and advocacy groups raise concerns regarding the plan’s implementation and transparency.

Speaking at the COP29 climate summit in Baku, Azerbaijan, last week, Hashim Djojohadikusumo, special envoy for climate and energy and brother to President Prabowo Subianto, stated that Jakarta intends to prioritize the use of degraded lands over clearing forests to achieve national food self-sufficiency. “We are protecting primary forests while increasing the productivity of existing and degraded lands,” Hashim said. “In our efforts to achieve food self-sufficiency, we have decided not to use primary forests and will continue to protect and conserve them diligently.”

image

DiCaprio, who has previously criticized the environmental impact of large-scale development in Papua, praised the policy shift in a social media post. “The Merauke project in South Papua would have been the largest planned deforestation programme on the planet. Instead, Indonesia has chosen to embark on what is likely to be the world’s largest restoration programme,” the actor wrote, characterizing the decision as a demonstration that food security and climate protection can be aligned.

Despite the positive reception, conservationists and researchers emphasize that the policy lacks critical geographic and legal details. Herry Purnomo, a forest management expert at IPB University, noted that the designation of land is essential to determining the environmental outcome. “When talking about forests, the ‘where’ is crucial,” Purnomo said. He warned that if degraded forest areas, such as those within the Tesso Nilo National Park, are targeted for conversion, it would constitute a misuse of land that requires ecological rehabilitation rather than agricultural development.

image

The Indonesian Ministry of Forestry recently identified 9.7 million hectares of degraded land potentially suitable for state-backed projects. However, the ministry has not yet disclosed specific locations or detailed land-use plans. Ristianto Pribadi, a spokesman for the ministry, confirmed that there is currently no formal policy revision following the special envoy’s statement. He noted that any adjustments would require technical evaluations and that existing permits do not automatically alter the legal status of forest areas.

Environmental group Walhi expressed further reservations, warning that repurposing fire-damaged land for development could create perverse incentives. Musdalifah Jamal, a campaigner at Walhi, cautioned that if burned land is readily converted into national strategic project areas, it might encourage the use of fire as an easy land-clearing method. Walhi records indicate that a significant portion of forest fires in Indonesia occur within corporate concessions, including those linked to national strategic projects.

image

As the government navigates these conflicting objectives, the central challenge remains reconciling the stated goal of food self-sufficiency with the preservation of natural ecosystems. While officials have pledged to designate 8.3 million hectares for social forestry, experts remain wary of repeating past agricultural failures in regions like Kalimantan and Papua where poor soil structures undermined previous food estate models.

Sophia Mitchell

Sophia Mitchell reports on international affairs, global developments, and major events across regions. She brings readers reliable updates and useful context on the people, decisions, and challenges shaping an interconnected world.
Back to top button