World News

Houthi Attacks Fuel Senate Scrutiny of U.S.-Saudi Nuclear Deal

Rising violence in the Middle East has prompted concerns over the security of a proposed U.S.-Saudi nuclear agreement ahead of a key Senate vote.

Intensifying Houthi attacks against critical infrastructure in Saudi Arabia are complicating the path for a proposed U.S.-Saudi nuclear energy pact, as U.S. senators prepare to vote on a resolution of disapproval. The ongoing campaign of drone and missile strikes, which has targeted airports, oil facilities, and commercial office buildings, has renewed congressional debate regarding the security of proposed nuclear sites that would be constructed under the agreement.

The deal, formally known as a 123 Agreement, was submitted to Congress by President Donald Trump in August. As the Senate prepares to vote on the resolution—potentially as early as the week of November 30—lawmakers have raised alarm over several provisions, or the lack thereof, in the proposal. Critics note that the pact fails to require the “Additional Protocol,” which grants the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) intrusive powers, such as snap inspections, that the U.S. previously demanded in negotiations with Iran.

Concerns regarding the agreement primarily focus on the potential for future weaponization, though the current wave of Houthi violence has highlighted the risk of militant strikes on nuclear assets. Henry Sokolski, executive director of the Nonproliferation Policy Education Center, and George Washington University research professor Sharon Squassoni recently argued in the National Interest that the U.S. should prioritize stricter safety requirements. “The last thing Washington should do is to build a bomb starter kit in Saudi Arabia, only for the Yemenis—or some other hostile group—to take it over,” they wrote.

Additionally, the deal has faced scrutiny because it does not require Saudi Arabia to normalize relations with Israel, a condition that had been widely expected as a prerequisite for sharing U.S. nuclear technology. Although President Trump stated that the deal would only proceed if Riyadh normalizes ties, congressional aides reported that the official documents submitted for legislative review contained no such condition.

U.S. Representative Brad Sherman, a California Democrat and senior member of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, criticized the administration for allowing a civil nuclear program to proceed without robust safeguards. “This is exactly what the Trump administration is allowing MBS to do,” Sherman wrote in the Washington Post, referring to Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, who has stated that while he does not wish to pursue nuclear weapons, he would do so if Iran acquires them.

In defense of the proposal, a White House official maintained that the agreement is intended for civilian purposes and would provide significant benefits to American industry and energy supply chains. IAEA chief Rafael Grossi also noted this week that the inspection provisions are “very satisfactory,” despite the absence of the Additional Protocol.

While the outcome of the Senate vote remains uncertain—with Republicans holding a 53-47 majority and some members reportedly requesting further information—the administration is expected to veto any resolution of disapproval if it passes. Supporters of the resolution argue that even a close vote could force greater transparency and influence future efforts to restrict the pact if the congressional majority shifts next year. Andrea Stricker, deputy director of the Nonproliferation Program at the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies, noted that a Democratic-led Congress could retain options to block transfers by placing conditions on nuclear exports and related funding.

Sophia Mitchell

Sophia Mitchell reports on international affairs, global developments, and major events across regions. She brings readers reliable updates and useful context on the people, decisions, and challenges shaping an interconnected world.
Back to top button