Business

Erewhon’s $749 Thanksgiving Feast Highlights U.S. Economic Divide

The divide in the American economy is manifesting at the holiday dinner table this year, as consumers choose between budget-friendly grocery store options and high-end, pre-made feasts. While the American Farm Bureau Federation’s 41st annual Thanksgiving dinner survey estimates the average cost of a meal for 10 people at $58.63—a 6.3% increase over 2025—retailers are catering to vastly different customer segments.

At the premium end of the spectrum, the Los Angeles-based luxury grocer Erewhon is offering an “ultimate organic feast” priced at $749. Designed to feed eight to 10 people, the meal costs approximately $74.90 per person and includes a free-range turkey, sourdough and roasted vegetable stuffing, rainbow carrots, Brussels sprouts, garlic mashed potatoes, turkey gravy, and a deep-dish pumpkin pie. The price point has drawn significant attention online, with digital creator Brandon Hau describing the offering as a “social experiment” in an Instagram video.

Experts note that while such luxury items exist to meet a specific market demand, they are not representative of broader economic realities. Ricky Volpe, a professor in the Agribusiness department at Cal Poly San Luis Obispo, explained that conventional grocery stores are tasked with maintaining price points accessible to households across all income levels, whereas retailers like Erewhon and Whole Foods appeal to a different demographic. “The Erewhon meal is sort of an interesting anecdote, and it exists because there’s a demand for that sort of thing, but that’s not in any way reflective of affordability in the United States,” Volpe said.

image

For many shoppers, ready-made meals represent a premium for convenience, covering costs for labor, preparation, and packaging rather than just the raw ingredients. Jeffrey Dorfman, a professor of Agricultural and Resource Economics at North Carolina State University, noted that while consumers can purchase ingredients to cook a meal for significantly less than $100, some choose to pay for the time saved. “There are people who do spend hundreds of dollars, maybe even $1,000, if they buy some nice wine and three or four different pies for desserts,” Dorfman said.

Retailers across Southern California are offering a range of price points for pre-made holiday meals:

– Vallarta Supermarkets is offering an $89.99 meal for six to eight guests, averaging $11.24 per person.
– Ralphs is providing a meal for six to eight people for $95, or $11.87 per person.
– Sprouts is promoting an organic turkey meal for six at $129.99, or $21.66 per person.
– Bristol Farms is offering a meal for eight to 12 guests for $279.99, or $23.33 per person.
– Whole Foods Market has a “Thanksgiving Extravaganza for 12” priced at $599.99, or $49.99 per person.

Despite the variety of options, the conversation surrounding the high cost of luxury offerings continues, with social media commentary reflecting the wide disparity in how different households approach the holiday budget.

Mia Reynolds

Mia Reynolds covers companies, entrepreneurship, leadership, and changing industries. She turns complex business developments into accessible stories, helping readers follow corporate decisions, market shifts, and trends influencing the global business landscape.
Back to top button