Entertainment

Elizabeth Holmes Documentary ‘You Can See Everything’ Faces Criticism Over Portrayal

While the documentary profiling Elizabeth Holmes has seen significant commercial success, critics argue it obscures the severity of her criminal conduct.

The documentary “You Can See Everything,” which chronicles the final months before convicted Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes entered prison, has achieved notable commercial success, grossing $94 million since its release. While the film, directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, has been lauded as a compelling psychological drama, it has also sparked significant debate regarding its portrayal of the former biotechnology executive.

Holmes was sentenced to 11 years in prison in 2022 after being found guilty of four counts of defrauding investors in her blood-testing startup, Theranos. The documentary offers an intimate, fly-on-the-wall perspective, capturing Holmes as she navigates her family life and impending incarceration. However, critics suggest that the film’s focus on her personal life—highlighting her role as a mother and her claims of innocence—may offer a sympathetic narrative that elides the factual harm caused by her company’s actions.

In an essay for Stat News, Theranos whistleblower Tyler Shultz criticized the film, stating, “What it certainly is not is a documentary, and it’s dangerous to pretend that it is.” Shultz and other observers have pointed to significant omissions in the documentary’s narrative, particularly regarding the real-world consequences of Theranos’s failed technology.

While Holmes was not convicted of patient-related charges, the impact on those who utilized the company’s services was documented as extensive. Reports indicate that patients received erroneous test results, including false diagnoses for cancer and heart attacks, which in some instances led to unnecessary medical treatments or emergency room visits. Additionally, internal company documents and testimony have previously revealed a culture of intimidation at Theranos, where employees were subjected to keystroke monitoring, non-disclosure agreements, and aggressive legal threats.

Among the most cited instances of the company’s conduct is the treatment of Ian Gibbons, the company’s former chief scientist. Gibbons, who became disillusioned with the company’s lack of progress, died by suicide in 2013 after being subpoenaed in a patent dispute. The film reportedly avoids questioning Holmes regarding her interactions with Gibbons and his widow, Rochelle, who spent years seeking accountability for his death.

Furthermore, the documentary has faced scrutiny over its presentation of Holmes’s financial status. The film depicts Holmes and her husband, Billy Evans, living in modest, austere accommodations. This portrayal contrasts with reports regarding the couple’s previous living arrangements on the Green Gables estate and elsewhere. Critics question whether these depictions reflect genuine financial hardship or a calculated attempt to craft a “girl-next-door” public image. While the filmmakers include an awkward moment in which Evans requests payment for their participation, the financial reality remains a point of contention.

Despite its acclaim as a piece of cinema, “You Can See Everything” leaves audiences to reconcile the film’s intimate character study with the established legal reality of Holmes’s crimes. For many, the documentary’s failure to address the full scope of the deception and the harm inflicted upon patients, employees, and families remains a primary source of tension.

Grace Morgan

Grace Morgan writes about movies, television, music, celebrities, and streaming culture. She follows major releases and entertainment industry developments, offering engaging updates and context on the creative work and trends capturing public attention.
Back to top button