California Voters Reject Wealth Tax, Ban Future Asset Levies
Voters defeated a proposed 5% tax on billionaire wealth while narrowly approving a ban on future levies on financial assets, marking a significant setback for progressive tax reform.
California voters rejected a high-profile proposal to impose a wealth tax on the state’s billionaires while simultaneously approving a ballot measure that creates significant new obstacles for future efforts to tax financial assets.
Proposition 40, which would have established a one-time 5% levy on the wealth of Californians with a net worth exceeding $1 billion, failed at the ballot box, with 52% of voters opposing the measure. In a concurrent move, voters narrowly passed Proposition 42, which restricts the state from enacting future taxes on financial assets. This new constitutional barrier cannot be overridden by state lawmakers and requires a future voter-approved measure to be repealed.
The fight over the billionaire tax was marked by an intense, multi-million dollar campaign. Opponents of the proposal, supported by significant donations from prominent tech figures including Google co-founder Sergey Brin and former Google CEO Eric Schmidt, outspent supporters by a 10-to-1 margin. The opposition coalition, which included the California Taxpayers Association, warned that the tax would prompt the ultra-wealthy to exit the state, potentially harming California’s income tax revenue.
“We were hopefully optimistic based on the polls that voters would agree with us that Prop. 40 was just a horrible idea for the state and Prop. 42 provides some important protections going forward,” said David Kline, spokesperson for the California Taxpayers Association.
The proposal faced challenges beyond the heavy opposition spending. Gov. Gavin Newsom vocally opposed the measure, arguing it represented a poor financial strategy for the state. Even among proponents, the path was not smooth; internal divisions among organized labor—specifically opposition or lack of support from groups like the California Teachers Association and Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California—complicated the campaign.
Despite the setback, advocates of the billionaire tax, including U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders, U.S. Rep. Ro Khanna, and SEIU United Healthcare Workers West, signaled that their efforts are not over. Proponents have indicated they plan to revisit the concept of wealth taxation in the 2028 election cycle.
“The game is up, people have had it and this election is just the beginning,” Khanna said on election night.
The California outcome stands in contrast to recent tax-the-rich trends in other parts of the United States. Voters in Washington state upheld a 9.9% tax on household income exceeding $1 million, while Colorado adopted a graduated income tax with higher rates for top earners. Similar income-based tax measures were recently approved by legislatures in Hawaii, Maine, and Rhode Island.
Carl Davis, research director at the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, noted that while the billionaire tax failed in California, the broader trend shows “a really good batting average” for proponents of progressive tax policies. He suggested that the California result was particularly influenced by the scale of opposition funding and internal labor disputes.
Looking ahead, California Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra, who opposed Proposition 40, acknowledged that the measure’s substantial support indicates widespread voter concern regarding tax fairness. While he did not provide a specific policy path forward, he remarked that the vote sent “a clear signal” that many Californians believe the current tax system is not equitable.
Lorena Gonzalez, president of the California Federation of Labor Unions, emphasized the need to persist with the policy goals. “We have to go back to the ballot,” Gonzalez said. “We’ve got to keep fighting.”