Andrew Scott Shines in ‘Elsinore,’ but Film Struggles to Keep Pace
In ‘Elsinore,’ Andrew Scott delivers a performance of remarkable intensity, portraying the real-life actor Ian Charleson as he navigates the final days of his life while starring as Hamlet at London’s National Theatre in 1989. While Scott’s work anchors the film with a searing, visceral reality, the production often falters by failing to trust both the strength of its lead actor and the intelligence of its audience.
Director Simon Stone captures a standout moment during one of Charleson’s stays in the Royal Free Hospital’s AIDS ward. As Ian prepares for an imminent visit, the camera lingers on Scott’s face, tracing a complex, shifting landscape of dread, fear, sorrow, and ultimately, resolve. It is a quiet, masterful sequence that demonstrates the effectiveness of simply allowing a skilled actor to do the work. Unfortunately, the film frequently pulls away from this restraint, opting instead for what might be described as dramaturgical training wheels. Stefan Gregory’s score, for instance, is often too insistent, seemingly designed to manipulate the audience’s emotional response rather than letting the narrative breathe.
The film is at its best when it focuses on the practical, technical rituals of Ian’s life. Sequences depicting him scanning his body for Kaposi’s Sarcoma lesions, attending medical appointments, and engaging in the exhausting, mundane mechanics of theatre rehearsals—memorizing dialogue and refining fight choreography—provide a grounded, compelling look at a man confronting his own mortality while clinging to his craft.
However, these strengths are periodically undercut by a desire to heighten the melodrama. The film leans on reaction shots of teary-eyed audience members—including Olivia Colman as Ian’s doctor—which feel unnecessary given the strength of Scott’s performance. Furthermore, the handling of Ian’s relationship with activist and filmmaker Derek Jarman, played by David Dawson, feels strained. The script attempts to manufacture a conflict regarding the closet that ignores the historical characterization of Jarman, resulting in a narrative choice that rings false.
On a more successful note, the film does not shy away from the pitch-black humor adopted by Ian’s friend group. This camaraderie, which uses biting wit as psychic armor to navigate constant tragedy, offers an authentic look at the era. Ultimately, the film stands as a showcase for Scott’s talent, yet it remains a frustrating experience. If ‘Elsinore’ had the courage to embrace the raw, unprocessed emotions already embedded in its story, rather than reaching for tidy, pre-digested sentiment, the full power of that performance would be realized.