Global Climate Policies Rely on Unproven Carbon Capture Technology

International climate commitments often rely on the promise of carbon capture and storage, but experts warn the technology remains unproven and climate models may be built on unrealistic assumptions.
International climate agreements and corporate “net-zero” pledges are frequently underpinned by the promise that fossil fuel emissions can be mitigated through carbon capture and storage (CCS). This technology, which involves trapping carbon dioxide from industrial sources and burying it deep underground, has received significant endorsement from the United Nations and is now a central component of global climate strategy. However, a joint investigation by ProPublica and Drilled suggests that reliance on this technology rests on thin evidence, as many large-scale projects have struggled to perform as expected.
Over the past three decades, the industry has developed only 12 large-scale geologic storage projects. Of these, at least seven have either underperformed or failed entirely. Data shows that the total amount of carbon dioxide buried globally last year was less than the annual emissions from a single large power plant. Despite these shortcomings, many global climate models—which guide policy and set pathways for preventing catastrophic warming—assume that CCS will work at a massive scale, often calculating success rates as high as 92%.
These climate models are influential but largely opaque. Unlike much scientific research, which relies on public, peer-reviewed data, modelers are not always required to document every assumption built into their simulations. In interviews with leaders of three of the world’s most influential climate models—based in the Netherlands, Germany, and Austria—researchers acknowledged that their projections rely on a mix of legitimate studies, unreviewed white papers, and anecdotal evidence.
Keywan Riahi, who leads the Austrian-based climate model, maintains that capturing concentrated CO2 from industrial emissions is a straightforward process. He argues that high capture rates are reasonable because models account for economic incentives, such as government subsidies and carbon taxes, which he believes will drive future implementation. Conversely, other experts have raised concerns about the technical limitations of the technology. For instance, at the Chevron-operated Gorgon natural gas plant in Australia, which was once billed as the world’s largest CCS operation, technical difficulties such as clogged wells and pressure spikes have forced operators to release much of the captured CO2 into the atmosphere.
Many of these optimistic assumptions stem from a 2005 U.N. report, which portrayed underground CO2 storage capacity as practically limitless. The report was authored with contributions from representatives of major oil companies, including Saudi Aramco, Chevron, and Shell. While the U.N. and contributing scientists have defended the report, recent research published in the journal Nature suggests the earth’s actual capacity for CO2 storage may be far more constrained than previously believed, particularly when accounting for geological risks like earthquake zones or areas unsuitable for injection.
Transparency regarding these risks varies among modelers. When asked whether his model accounts for the possibility of carbon leaks over long time horizons, Detlef van Vuuren, head of the Dutch climate model, answered in the negative. Similarly, Jessica Strefler, who leads the German-based model, indicated that there is no robust data for storage limits, forcing her team to rely on qualitative “expert interviews” within the industry to set parameters.
Proponents argue that these models act as “recipes” for the future rather than predictions, designed to show that meeting climate targets is theoretically possible if CCS is deployed at scale. They suggest that the current delay in global climate action has left few other tools to address warming. Yet, as critics point out, a recipe that relies on ingredients that have not been proven to function at scale risks building a climate strategy on potentially unrealistic foundations.