California Coastal Buyout Strategy Remains Stalled Despite Rising Sea Threats

As high tides and El Niño threaten California's coastline, experts and officials are revisiting a proposed 'buy-and-rent-back' program to address long-term sea level rise.
The arrival of exceptionally high king tides and a strong El Niño weather cycle has once again exposed the vulnerability of California’s shoreline. With storm-battered boardwalks and tidal flooding becoming increasingly common, climate adaptation experts are renewing calls for a proactive, state-led strategy to manage the encroachment of the Pacific Ocean.
For years, the default response to coastal erosion has relied on emergency measures: sandbags, berms, and seawalls. While these interventions offer immediate relief, planners warn that they are ultimately futile against long-term sea level rise and often exacerbate the problem by disrupting the natural shoreline. An alternative proposal, known as a “buy-and-rent-back” program, would see the government purchase at-risk beachfront properties, rent them out to recoup costs until the land becomes untenable, and eventually transition the area into public space or natural coastal protection.
This strategy, which proponents argue is both forward-thinking and economically sound, has faced significant legislative setbacks. State Sen. Ben Allen (D-Santa Monica) championed the concept through two separate bills, Senate Bill 83 in 2021 and Senate Bill 1078 in 2022. While SB 83 successfully navigated the state Legislature—receiving a 33-2 approval vote in the Senate and passing through committee hearings without registered opposition—it was ultimately vetoed by Gov. Gavin Newsom. A subsequent, more refined version, SB 1078, met the same fate.
In his veto messages, the governor cited concerns regarding the lack of a comprehensive approach to the long-term costs associated with such a program. However, proponents contend that the financial risk of inaction is far greater. According to legislative analysts who assessed the situation in 2019, an estimated $8 billion to $10 billion in coastal property could be underwater by 2050, with an additional $6 billion to $10 billion at risk during high tides. Research by the National Institute of Building Sciences has suggested that for every $1 spent on pre-disaster acquisition or demolition of flood-prone properties, society saves at least $6 in avoided emergency costs.
“The idea was, how do we change the game with regard to the costs and liabilities?” said Sen. Allen, who developed the proposal after consulting with coastal planners, local officials, and legal experts at UCLA. The goal was to provide homeowners with a voluntary exit strategy, allowing them to sell properties at a fair value before they were destroyed, while preventing taxpayers from assuming the massive burden of emergency cleanups following inevitable disasters.
Experts emphasize that the urgency for such a mechanism is only increasing. Julia Stein, deputy director of the Emmett Institute on Climate Change and the Environment at the UCLA School of Law, noted that a planned, non-catastrophic relocation strategy is essential. “Everything that we’re seeing with El Niño right now shows that we need a planning mechanism like this,” Stein said. Charles Lester, director of the Ocean and Coastal Policy Center at UC Santa Barbara, added that without an orderly process, communities are left to rely on ad hoc, reactive measures, such as homeowners piling boulders on beaches to hold back the sea.
The reality of the status quo is visible in towns like Pacifica, where the 2015-16 El Niño season left apartment buildings teetering on the edge of crumbling cliffs. The emergency response for that season alone cost the town $16 million, a substantial figure for a municipality with a $36 million operating budget. John Keener, the former mayor of Pacifica, expressed regret that the buy-and-rent-back proposal did not move forward.
“What happened instead was… nothing,” Keener said, reflecting on the ongoing destruction of local infrastructure, including the demolition of the community’s pier and local businesses. As California continues to experience extreme weather cycles, including recent storm damage in Huntington Beach and coastal erosion across the state, the debate over how to balance short-term property protection with long-term climate adaptation remains a difficult, unresolved challenge.