The Movie Magic Behind the Dolphin Cove Police Station

Production designers transform a humble Australian beach cafe into a police station for the television series Return to Paradise using clever visual tricks.
The Stanwell Park beach kiosk, typically an unassuming cafe in a northern suburb of Wollongong, New South Wales, undergoes a periodic metamorphosis for the television series Return to Paradise. For three days at a time, the beachside cottage is repurposed to serve as the Dolphin Cove Police Station, a central location for the show’s fictional murder mysteries.
Victoria Williams, the production designer for the series, approaches set construction with a guiding principle: effective design should be nearly imperceptible. “You want it to look effortless. Design should always look 99 per cent invisible,” Williams said.
Achieving this result requires a day of labor from a specialist crew. The transformation centers on the use of lightweight modular walls, or “flats,” which are transported to the site to conceal existing features like servery windows and blackboard menus. These panels form a false exterior wall, designed with vertical paneling and colored glass windows. The construction serves a dual purpose: it creates a convincing police station facade while simultaneously housing the production’s cameras and lighting equipment.
The art department integrates local elements to blend the structure into the coastal landscape. Lattice, flowering bougainvillea, and a mix of real and artificial greenery are placed around the verandah, effectively masking the kiosk’s permanent furniture. Even the exterior police sign, which appears to be a permanent fixture, is a mobile prop secured by weighted bags that are hidden by vines.
Maintaining the show’s signature aesthetic relies heavily on perspective. Filming is strictly controlled, with certain angles—specifically from the eastern side—prohibited to keep production brackets and equipment out of the frame. Furthermore, the show relies on a specific “eternal sunshine” look. To maintain this consistency, the lighting department uses large overhead blue lights to replicate sunlight, a task complicated by shifting cloud cover. Williams noted that the lighting crew must constantly monitor weather conditions to ensure the station’s exterior remains bright and sunny, even when the natural light suggests otherwise.
The geography of the fictional Dolphin Cove is equally curated. While the exterior of the police station is located at Stanwell Park, interior scenes are filmed in a Western Sydney studio approximately 60 kilometers away. The fictional town is a patchwork, with scenes filmed across various locations, including Wombarra, Coledale, and Austinmer, as well as suburbs on Sydney’s Northern Beaches.
Inside the station, the design team employs creative solutions to balance the demands of a procedural drama with the show’s lighthearted “cosy crime” tone. For the third season, the team constructed a holding cell using a mix of timber and plastic that mimics the appearance of metal. Williams noted that these bars are intentionally designed to be non-threatening. To reinforce the show’s identity, the department uses a custom color dubbed “Dolphin Cove Teal” (DCT) on the cell bars, a shade that appears subtly throughout the series to anchor the audience in the fictional town.
Beyond the architecture, the production team pays meticulous attention to set dressing. Every item on the characters’ desks is intentional. Lead detective Mack’s desk, for instance, features a temperamental lamp that the character is often shown adjusting, adding a layer of lived-in authenticity. The background is filled with fabricated community notices, police files, and even “Easter eggs”—such as references to crew members or past plot points—hidden in community posters and honor boards.
For local cafe owner Joel Murdoch, seeing his business transformed into a law enforcement hub remains a novel experience. “The plant life that they bring in is so much better than what it actually is in real life,” Murdoch said. He also observed that fans of the show have begun making “the pilgrimage” to the cafe and other filming locations, such as the nearby Coledale Surf Club, to photograph the site.
For Williams, the ultimate validation comes when the production crew themselves become temporarily convinced by the set. “Sometimes they won’t realise stuff is fake … then they’re like, ‘Oh my God, I’ve just realised!’ It’s so wonderful when you realise that you’ve even tricked the crew,” she said. Ultimately, the intricate work behind the scenes is designed to fade into the background, leaving the viewer entirely immersed in the narrative—a testament to the effectiveness of the show’s visual sleight of hand.