JobsOhio Demands $1 Million Repayment From Failed Biotech Project

The state’s private economic development agency, JobsOhio, has formally requested the repayment of a $1 million grant from AquaBounty Technologies following the collapse of a planned genetically engineered salmon farm in Pioneer, Ohio. According to an AquaBounty filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the company was notified in September that its efforts to sell off equipment and consider acquisition offers for the site constituted a breach of their grant agreement.
JobsOhio, which operates as a private entity with a board appointed by the governor and funding supported by the state, issued the repayment demand after determining the company failed to meet agreed-upon performance metrics. The project, announced in 2021, was envisioned as the largest investment in the history of rural Williams County, promising 112 new jobs alongside infrastructure and school resources. Under the original grant terms, the company was required to reach a payroll of over $5.4 million and make a $222 million capital investment by the end of 2026, maintaining those commitments through 2028.

Construction of the facility stalled with the site only 30% complete. By the end of September, AquaBounty reported having only three employees and $122,255 in cash on hand. The company has since sold off equipment intended for the Ohio site, as well as its intellectual property related to genetically engineered salmon. AquaBounty noted in its SEC filing that it is in discussions with JobsOhio, but cautioned that there is no guarantee the agency will agree to an accommodation or payment schedule. The company warned that legal or collection action could result in further management distraction and additional costs.
Local scrutiny of the project has been significant, particularly regarding the role of Pioneer Mayor Ed Kidston. Records indicated that Kidston purchased land desired for the plant and subsequently sold it to the company for $1.5 million more than his initial purchase price. Kidston did not respond to requests for comment, though he previously stated his involvement was intended to assist the community. Sherry Fleming of the Williams County Alliance, a local environmental group, criticized the state’s eagerness to fund an unproven industry. She stated that the lack of due diligence regarding the company’s limited production experience placed taxpayer dollars at unnecessary risk.

Matt Englehart, a spokesperson for JobsOhio, stated that while the agency operates with transparency and accountability, it cannot comment on matters that may lead to litigation. He noted that the organization typically works with businesses to help them overcome challenges when metrics are not met, but will pursue the recovery of funds if necessary. Kristan Wong Karinen, a research analyst with the nonprofit Good Jobs First, noted that while clawbacks are relatively rare, the severity of the failure in this instance left the state with little choice.
As of November, JobsOhio has maintained its demand for the $1 million return. The agency has indicated that if the funds are not repaid, it may refer the matter to collections and pursue other available legal remedies.