Police Investigate NHS Grampian Following Whistleblower Allegations of Avoidable Deaths

Police Scotland has launched an investigation into NHS Grampian following whistleblower allegations that multiple patients suffered avoidable deaths while under the care of the health board.
The investigation follows claims made by Dr. Mohammed Meer Habib, a surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, who alleged that hundreds of patients may have experienced significant harm or avoidable deaths in recent years. Dr. Habib, a medic with 36 years of experience, characterized the hospital environment in critical terms during a press conference held in Glasgow.

Detective Superintendent Carron McKellar of Police Scotland confirmed the department received a report in 2024 concerning several deaths. “Enquiries are being carried out, and a situational report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal,” McKellar stated.
Dr. Habib has called for a corporate homicide investigation, specifically citing concerns that patients died from blood loss following operations at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary. As part of his public disclosures, he released an unpublished 2022 expert review. The document found that 19 of 45 patients examined in the liver and pancreatic surgery department experienced avoidable deaths, with some fatalities occurring in the operating theater due to surgical errors.

The surgeon stated that he opted to go public after failing to receive satisfactory responses to several letters sent to health officials, the Scottish Government, Police Scotland, and the Crown Office. Records indicate Dr. Habib sent four letters to the Scottish Government: one to then-First Minister Humza Yousaf in 2023, and three to First Minister John Swinney in October 2024, November 2025, and May 2026.
Responding to the correspondence, the Scottish Government informed Dr. Habib that it lacked jurisdiction to investigate whistleblowing and individual health boards. First Minister Swinney stated he only became aware of the correspondence on the day of the press conference, noting that because the letters concerned clinical matters, they were handled by government officials to ensure they were directed to the relevant authorities.
A spokesperson for the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) confirmed that the concerns raised by Dr. Habib are being treated seriously. “Given the complexity and breadth of the issues raised, inquiries remain ongoing,” the spokesperson said.
The allegations against NHS Grampian come amid broader scrutiny of the health board, which was subject to a recent report identifying risks to children caused by managerial issues. Opposition parties have seized on the situation to criticize the current government, claiming the case highlights a systemic culture where management is shielded from accountability while whistleblowers are ignored. Dr. Habib maintained that he was prepared to risk his career to ensure the public understands the extent of the alleged issues.