DOJ Drops Alaska Senate Election Lawsuit, Citing Mootness

The U.S. Department of Justice has formally moved to abandon its legal challenge regarding the certification of Alaska’s U.S. Senate election. In a filing submitted to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday, the department characterized the case as “moot,” effectively signaling an end to efforts that sought to potentially block the finalization of the state’s electoral results.
The department’s shift comes as Democratic candidate Mary Peltola leads the electoral tally, with projections indicating she has won the race—a result that would mark a ninth Senate pickup for Democrats in the upcoming Congress. President Donald Trump had previously directed the Justice Department to initiate the litigation to preemptively block certification should Republican incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan lose, citing concerns over potential voter confusion between candidates with similar names.

Republicans had alleged that a candidate named Dan J. Sullivan operated a campaign intended to confuse voters and divert support from Sen. Dan S. Sullivan. A federal judge in Alaska had previously dismissed the suit on Nov. 1, citing the lack of a “workable plan” to investigate the impact of the name similarities on submitted ballots.
In the latest filing, Stanley Woodward, the third-ranked official at the Justice Department, requested that the 9th Circuit vacate the district judge’s dismissal order while concurrently acknowledging that further litigation is not warranted. Woodward stated, “This Court should deny the motion to summarily affirm the district court’s judgment. Instead, this Court should vacate the district court’s order dismissing this lawsuit, because the case has become moot.”

Woodward further noted the department’s position that it was unable to address disputes regarding ballots that may have been intended for the incumbent senator. “The United States therefore reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means of ‘determin[ing] whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant to be cast for Senator Sullivan’ and vindicating the United States’ asserted injury,” he wrote.
The motion follows repeated public calls from President Trump, who had advocated for the Alaska results to be resolved in favor of the incumbent senator by aggregating the vote totals of Dan J. Sullivan and another candidate whom the administration alleged was recruited by Democrats to act as a spoiler. Despite these efforts, the department’s latest filing indicates that the legal path to challenging the outcome has effectively closed.