From ‘Virgin River’ to ‘The Witcher’: Ranking TV’s Best Guilty Pleasures

While prestige television series frequently capture Emmy Awards, critical acclaim, and cultural seriousness, viewers often crave lighter entertainment that embraces melodrama and comforting absurdity rather than heavy drama. A distinct line separates genuine so-bad-it’s-good television from spiteful hate-watching. Comforting, joyful viewing experiences—rather than draining, snark-inducing social media fodder—define the ten best so-bad-it’s-good television shows available to stream, excluding reality programming.
At number 10 sits Netflix’s “Virgin River,” a cozy, soapy drama that Netflix recently announced is returning for a ninth season, making it the streaming service’s longest-running drama. Filled with attractive actors and natural backdrops, the show functions as a comforting television comfort watch without aiming for awards. Ninth is ABC’s “Once Upon a Time” (now on Disney+ and Hulu), which combined fairy tales, suburban parents with amnesia, and “Frozen” elements into Desperate Housewives-style antics.

In the eighth spot, Tom Selleck’s 1980s detective classic “Magnum P.I.” (available on Roku) embraced cheesy dialogue, over-the-top plots, and hammy stunts as a badge of honor. Seventh place goes to Netflix’s “Emily in Paris,” starring Lily Collins as an American transplant navigating high fashion, culture shock, and relationship woes ahead of its sixth and final season this December. Sixth is Canada’s “Degrassi: The Next Generation” on HBO Max, which captured Millennial guilty-pleasure viewing with preposterous plots, crocodile tears, and constant plot repetition.
Fifth on the list is Freeform’s “Pretty Little Liars,” a seven-season series about teenage girls stalked by an anonymous tormentor, featuring endless mysteries and cast members aging into their 30s while maintaining the illusion of high school. It streams on Disney+, Hulu, and HBO Max. Fourth is the 1990s syndicated hit “Xena: Warrior Princess” on Xumo, praised as a celebration of camp and a queer culture hero that stood out among low-budget, corny afternoon action shows.
Third is the CW’s “Riverdale” (streaming on Netflix), a dark Archie comics adaptation blending romance, mystic mystery, and unintentional comedy with boundless absurdity. Second is CBS’s early-2000s forensic staple “CSI: Miami” (streaming on Paramount+), where David Caruso and his sunglasses elevated cheesy detective drama to iconic heights.
Topping the list at number one is Netflix’s fantasy series “The Witcher.” While later seasons struggled, the Henry Cavill-led premiere era delivered a full B-movie experience embracing its video-game origins, featuring convoluted plots, stoic underacting, and the breakaway pop hit “Toss a Coin to Your Witcher.”