Judge Blocks D.C. Golf Course Closure Amid Trump Overhaul Plan

A federal judge has temporarily blocked the Trump administration from closing East Potomac Park and its historic golf course in Washington, D.C., dealing a temporary setback to plans to overhaul the property into a championship venue.
U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes issued the ruling on Saturday, siding with a D.C. preservation group and two local golfers. The plaintiffs had argued that the planned closure of the public course, which opened in the 1920s, was part of a broader administration effort to redesign and replace the facility with a layout designed by golf course architect Tom Fazio. Reyes’s order will remain in effect until Nov. 28.
President Trump criticized the decision in a Sunday social media post, defending the administration’s plans and describing the current state of the facility as a “terrible and very unsafe golf course.” He stated that the Interior Department possesses the absolute right to proceed and will immediately appeal what he termed a “highly destructive and political decision” on an expedited basis.
During court proceedings, Reyes concluded that the administration’s justifications for shuttering the park were pretextual, stating that the government reverse-engineered additional explanations for the closure while pursuing the president’s directive. She questioned why the site was not closed immediately if the situation was genuinely emergent, noting that thousands of runners participated in the Marine Corps Marathon through the park just last month.
Catherine Carroll, senior legal adviser at Democracy Forward, welcomed the ruling. She expressed gratitude that the court intervened to prevent what she described as irreparable harm caused by the administration’s pursuit of a vanity project that would eliminate a treasured public park.
A Department of Justice spokesperson countered that the National Park Service maintains the authority to limit access to facilities when the public faces risks of harm. The spokesperson added that nothing in the court’s order prevents planning for a world-class golf course from moving forward, and vowed that the department will vociferously defend the administration’s agenda.
The legal dispute escalated last month when the National Park Service notified the court of plans to remove trees on the course, subsequently cutting down more than 500 trees over a single weekend. Reyes responded by issuing an order blocking any additional tree felling and requiring the Justice Department to provide advance notice of future actions at the site.
The Trump administration later notified the court that the Interior Department intended to close both the golf course and the entirety of East Potomac Park, citing a deteriorating sea wall, safety hazards, and the departure of the course’s operating organization, the National Links Trust, as of Nov. 15. Lawyers for the plaintiffs argued that the administration manufactured the operator vacancy and found areas of disrepair to justify the closure. National Park Service records indicate there is currently no plan in place to fix the sea wall, a project estimated to cost more than $300 million and take at least two and a half years.
During a court hearing on Friday, Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward acknowledged he would be shocked to find an existing contract with Fazio or affiliated entities finalizing the new course plans and construction. Justice Department lawyer Adam Gustafson argued that agencies have limited resources and discretion, emphasizing that closing the park does not mean immediate renovation work will begin, as the National Park Service must still complete environmental and historic preservation reviews alongside forthcoming reviews by the Commission of Fine Arts and the National Capital Planning Commission.
Separately, Judge Reyes has initiated an inquiry into whether top officials from the Interior Department, Justice Department, and National Park Service misrepresented facts in court and violated ethics rules. Reyes stated her intention to appoint former U.S. Attorney Jessie Liu to lead the probe, which will examine whether government lawyers instructed agency officials to omit or include specific information in declarations regarding work at the course. The Justice Department opposes the appointment of a special master.