Trump’s Judicial Appointment Blitz Faces Resistance From Republican Senators

President Donald Trump’s final push to install as many lifetime federal judges as possible before Democrats assume control of the U.S. Senate is encountering unexpected resistance from several fellow Republicans.
During Trump’s second term, Senate Republicans had routinely approved his nominees for district and appeals courts, confirming 57 judges so far to cement a conservative imprint on the judiciary. However, as the White House and Senate Republican leaders press forward with judicial nominees during the lame-duck session, a handful of Republican senators have blocked or cast doubt on three nominees selected for their home states.
Under Senate custom, home-state senators traditionally help choose judges for vacancies and can block trial court nominees by withholding a favorable “blue slip” submitted to the Senate Judiciary Committee. While the White House has generally honored that tradition, it has sometimes bypassed objections from Republican senators to push through conservative choices.
“We put up a lot of really qualified candidates that we sent to the White House, and they basically ignored that and just put through their one,” said Senator Alan Armstrong, an Oklahoma Republican.
Outgoing Republican members of the Senate Judiciary Committee, including Thom Tillis of North Carolina and John Cornyn of Texas, possess the ability to deny targeted nominees the votes required to advance. On Tuesday, the White House took the rare step of withdrawing U.S. District Judge Lee Rudofsky’s nomination to the St. Louis-based 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Rudofsky was replaced by Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland following opposition from Arkansas U.S. Senators John Boozman and Tom Cotton. Tillis acknowledged he supported the Arkansas senators’ efforts to block Rudofsky.

Meanwhile, outgoing Senators Armstrong and Cornyn have withheld public support for nominees in their respective states, while Tillis has used his committee position to assist in blocking candidates opposed by colleagues. Tillis, whose relationship with Trump is fractured, told reporters that the White House has at times told senators to simply get on board with their chosen candidate. “That’s not how it works here,” Tillis said. “They should expect they’re going to get this response.”
For the White House, the coming weeks represent the concluding phase of a project launched during Trump’s first administration to shift the ideological balance of the federal judiciary to the right. Trump made 234 judicial appointments during his first term from 2017 to 2021, including three Supreme Court justices, leaving roughly one-third of active judges as Trump appointees.
“We expect all judicial nominees pending in the Senate to be confirmed this year,” a White House official stated. Senate Majority Leader John Thune said on Monday that judicial confirmations remain a top priority while Republicans retain control of the chamber. The Senate confirmed its first judicial nominee of the lame-duck session on Thursday, leaving 23 nominees pending. A vote is scheduled for Monday on the nomination of Colorado-based U.S. District Judge Daniel Domenico to the Denver-based 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
However, Tillis—who is retiring—and Cornyn—who lost a primary election to a Trump-backed challenger—are in their final days in office and have indicated a willingness to halt several pending nominees. Rob Luther, a George Mason University law professor who worked on judicial nominations in the White House Counsel’s Office during Trump’s first term, noted that senators on “borrowed time” are standing in the way of movement conservatives reaching the bench.
Cornyn has declined to commit to supporting T. Elliot Gaiser, Trump’s nominee for a federal judgeship in Dallas. Gaiser, who leads the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel and hails from Ohio, was selected without the usual senator-driven screening process in Texas, preventing him from appearing at a Wednesday Judiciary Committee hearing without Cornyn’s blue slip.
Tillis is also backing Armstrong’s opposition to Zach West, an Oklahoma attorney general’s office lawyer praised by conservative legal activists for defending abortion restrictions and supporting religious school participation in charter school programs. Although Armstrong initially returned a favorable blue slip for West, he later withdrew his support. Tillis’ backing leaves West short of the votes needed to clear the committee when it next decides on advancing nominees on Tuesday. The situation is further complicated because Armstrong leaves the Senate on November 30 and will be replaced by Senator-elect Kevin Hern, a Republican who could adopt a different stance on West. Tillis stated he will continue blocking the nominee for now, explaining, “When I’ve got two Republicans from the state telling me to move on it, I move on it. If I have one or more asking me not to, then I’m not.”