Voters Oust Sheriffs Linked to Federal Immigration Enforcement Pacts
Voters in several states have removed local sheriffs who aligned their offices with federal immigration enforcement agreements, signaling a shift in local law enforcement priorities.
Voters have unseated several sheriffs across the United States who maintained cooperation with federal immigration enforcement efforts, as recent election cycles saw candidates successfully campaign against the controversial pacts. The results highlight a potential political liability for local law enforcement leaders who have participated in the federal government’s 287(g) program, which deputizes local officers to enforce federal immigration law.
In North Carolina, the race for Alamance County sheriff saw longtime incumbent Republican Sheriff Terry Johnson defeated by Shannon Long, an independent who had campaigned on ending the office’s participation in the 287(g) program. Long, a pastor, business owner, and former sheriff’s deputy, described a local atmosphere where trust between the sheriff’s office and the county’s Latino community had become significantly strained. He noted that the campaign van he drove during the election became an obstacle because the word “sheriff” itself elicited fear among some residents.
“They’ve been living in fear. They feel like they don’t have a voice. They have been suppressed, oppressed; a lot of them are depressed. So they feel that they live in a community where they don’t belong,” Long said in an interview following his victory. The election in Alamance County, which has grown increasingly diverse, appeared to turn partly on questions surrounding immigration enforcement and the perceived treatment of Latino residents.
Johnson, a prominent and polarizing figure who had served as sheriff since 2002, initially suggested in a phone call that immigration policy may have contributed to his defeat. In a later interview, however, he attributed the loss to his long tenure and a broader political environment that proved difficult for Republicans in North Carolina. He maintained that he consistently followed the law and protected public safety. State Sen. Amy Galey, a Republican whose district includes the county, defended Johnson’s record on training and mental health services, questioning the extent to which immigration policy influenced the final vote, though she acknowledged that aggressive immigration tactics elsewhere might have contributed to general public concerns about law enforcement.
An analysis of approximately 250 sheriff elections held this month identified several races in Indiana, Maryland, North Carolina, Wisconsin, and other states where participation in immigration pacts played a role in the defeat of incumbents. The agreements have become a central element of the current administration’s deportation strategy. According to government data obtained by the Deportation Data Project and analyzed by the advocacy group fwd.us, there are now more than 2,700 such pacts with state and local agencies, an increase from 135 when the administration began its second term. These agreements have deputized over 29,000 local officers and, as of July, accounted for more than 6,600 arrests, representing about 15% of all arrests made by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
In Frederick County, Maryland, the sheriff’s office had long been a participant in the 287(g) program, detaining and turning over 1,884 people to ICE since 2008. However, the program effectively stopped this year after the state governor signed legislation banning immigration enforcement pacts with the federal government. Public sentiment also shifted against Republican Sheriff Chuck Jenkins, who was defeated by Democrat Karl Bickel, a former Department of Justice employee who had previously challenged Jenkins four times. While Jenkins argued that the program enhanced community safety, he acknowledged that his stance on the pact likely contributed to his loss.
Similarly, in Winnebago County, Wisconsin, the sheriff’s office’s participation in a 287(g) agreement became a focal point in the election, contributing to the victory of Democrat Jason Rippl, who pledged to terminate the agreement. Local advocates noted that the detention of a schoolteacher by ICE just weeks before Election Day created a backlash against any candidates perceived to be aligned with federal immigration enforcement, even when the local department was not involved in that specific arrest.
As the newly elected sheriff in Alamance County, Long intends to uphold the law and hold offenders accountable, but he does not plan to participate in the 287(g) program. He has initiated meetings with the local Latino community to establish new lines of communication, aiming to restore a sense of partnership with the sheriff’s office. While the current impact of these election results is limited to a small number of jurisdictions, the issue is expected to remain a significant factor in upcoming cycles, particularly in states like Texas and Florida, where large numbers of sheriffs currently operate under 287(g) agreements.