Senate Commerce Committee Advances FCC Nominee Amid Democratic Boycott

The Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee voted 15-0 on November 18 to advance an FCC nominee, proceeding without Democratic participation. Democratic members of the committee had announced their intention to boycott the vote in an attempt to deny the committee a quorum.
Leading up to the session, Democratic members expressed formal opposition to the committee’s decision to advance a third Republican nominee while a Democratic seat remains vacant. In a statement, ranking member Maria Cantwell said that all Democratic committee members objected to the majority’s efforts to “stacking independent commissions with Republicans” and criticized the pace of the confirmation process during the current lame-duck session.
In a letter sent to Committee Chairman Ted Cruz prior to the vote, the Democratic members urged him to cancel the proceedings. To bolster their argument, they cited comments made by Cruz in 2014, in which he stated that controversial nominees “should not be confirmed in the lame duck session of Congress by senators who just lost their seats and are no longer accountable to the voters.”
Responding to the criticism, Cruz defended the committee’s schedule, noting, “Democrats will control the Senate, unfortunately, in January. But today is November 18.” He added that there is “ample precedent” for moving forward with nominations during a lame-duck session.
The dispute over the quorum requirements highlighted a conflict between the committee’s internal rules and the Standing Rules of the Senate. While committee rules specify that a quorum for nomination votes must include “a majority of the members, which includes at least one minority member,” a spokesperson for Cruz pointed to different provisions in the broader Senate rules. Under paragraph 7 of rule XXVI of the Standing Rules of the Senate, a matter can be reported if a majority of the committee is “physically present,” with no requirement that minority members be in attendance. Furthermore, the rules state that no point of order may be raised against a measure if the committee acted in conformity with the requirements of paragraph 7.
In separate developments concerning agency procedures, communications indicate that the committee has been looking to shift the handling of complaints. In internal correspondence, staff discussed instructing complainants to resubmit “news distortion complaints” through the commission’s Electronic Comment Filing System (ECFS), with plans to draft guidance for consumers on how to navigate the system.
The committee’s decision to move forward despite the unified absence of the Democratic minority leaves the status of the nomination process subject to ongoing debate regarding the procedural weight of committee versus Senate rules.