World News

Routine Code-Switching May Not Sharpen the Brain, Expert Says

For many residents in Hong Kong, mixing Cantonese and English is a linguistic norm. While this habit of “code-switching” is often cited by international schools and proponents as a source of cognitive sharpness, new research suggests that everyday language mixing may not be the mental workout many assume.

Manson Fong Cheuk-man, a cognitive neuroscientist and research assistant professor at Hong Kong Polytechnic University, indicates that habitual “dense code-switching”—the seamless blending of languages in casual conversation—functions as a relaxed, default state for the brain. According to Fong, the brain processes these mixed phrases as pre-packaged chunks, requiring little cognitive effort to produce.

image

The research holds significance as Hong Kong faces an aging demographic. Government data shows that the population of residents aged 65 and over reached 25 percent last year and is projected to rise to 36 percent by 2046. The Hong Kong Mental Morbidity Survey for Older People, which analyzed data between 2019 and 2023, found that dementia affects nearly one in 10 adults aged 60 or older, a figure that climbs to nearly 50 percent for those aged 85 and above.

Fong contrasts casual mixing with conscious, controlled language use. He explains that if a person moves between languages for professional tasks—such as switching from an English-language meeting to a Cantonese-language client call—the brain must act like a “strict traffic cop,” keeping languages in separate lanes and actively suppressing the unused language. This process requires significantly more cognitive control.

image

To test how different linguistic challenges affect the brain, Fong’s team monitored participants while they learned Italian vocabulary inside an MRI scanner. The results showed that learning a new language engages various parts of the brain, including the superior temporal gyrus for speech sounds and the hippocampus for memory formation. Fong noted that some older participants performed as well as or better than younger adults, which he attributed to higher levels of dedication.

“Learning a language is truly a whole-brain process,” Fong stated. He argues that the cognitive benefits of bilingualism are tied to proficiency and the structural differences between languages, rather than just the act of switching. The study found that Cantonese-English bilinguals with higher proficiency in both languages exhibited better inhibitory control, or the ability to tune out distractions.

image

For those seeking to maintain cognitive health, Fong advises against forcing language switches in daily speech, as it can disrupt the natural flow of communication. Instead, he suggests challenging the brain by attempting to speak in a single language for an extended period or engaging with media like films and podcasts without the aid of subtitles. Ultimately, Fong emphasizes that language exercises are only one part of the equation, stressing that maintaining an active social life and participating in a wide variety of mental activities remain vital for keeping the aging brain engaged.

Sophia Mitchell

Sophia Mitchell reports on international affairs, global developments, and major events across regions. She brings readers reliable updates and useful context on the people, decisions, and challenges shaping an interconnected world.
Back to top button