Philadelphia Foster Mother Charged With Murder After Child Found Dead

A Philadelphia woman has been charged with murder following the discovery of her 10-year-old foster child’s body inside a vehicle in New Jersey. The case concludes a search that spanned more than a week and has drawn intense scrutiny toward the city’s child welfare system.
Carprice Williams, 36, was taken into custody and faces seven charges: murder, endangering the welfare of a child, criminal use of a communication facility, possession of an instrument of crime, abuse of a corpse, tampering with evidence, and recklessly endangering another person. Prosecutors announced the charges on November 5. During an arraignment on November 6, Williams was ordered held without bail. She is scheduled to appear in court again for a preliminary hearing on November 23.
According to the Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office, the victim, Malayshia Alford, was last seen alive at her West Philadelphia home on October 22. Assistant District Attorney Ashley Toczylowski stated during a November 5 press conference that investigators recovered surveillance footage from October 26 showing an unidentified person removing what appeared to be the girl’s body from the residence in a bag before placing it into a vehicle. District Attorney Larry Krasner confirmed that the individual seen in the footage was not Williams.
Authorities were able to track the vehicle depicted in the surveillance footage, which led them to a second vehicle located at an apartment complex in Lindenwold, New Jersey. The body of the 10-year-old was discovered inside the trunk of that vehicle on November 4. The Gloucester-Camden-Salem Counties Medical Examiner’s Office ruled the death a homicide, determining that the girl died from blunt force trauma. Toczylowski further noted that investigators have found evidence suggesting the child had been subjected to abuse prior to her death, stating, “We do have the indication that there were instances of abuse happening, and that items were used to carry out that abuse.”
The circumstances regarding Malayshia’s placement in the foster care system are now under investigation. Both the Philadelphia Police Department and the District Attorney’s Office intend to subpoena records from the city’s Department of Human Services to review the oversight and supervision provided during her time in Williams’ home. Marci Hamilton, a professor at the University of Pennsylvania and an expert on child abuse and neglect, indicated that the case highlights an urgent need for reforms within the city’s Department of Human Services.
The tragedy has led to a significant public outpouring of grief in Philadelphia. Community members have left tributes outside the West Philadelphia home, and students and teachers at Robert E. Lamberton School, where the girl was a student, have created memorials in her honor. Philadelphia Mayor Cherelle Parker issued a statement describing the event as one that had “shaken me to my core” and pledged that local law enforcement and the FBI would work to uncover the facts. Nafis Horne, the brother of the child’s biological father, asked for privacy and prayers as the family copes with the loss, requesting that the public avoid passing judgment during their mourning process.