NHS Whisteblower Sent Three Letters to John Swinney Over Avoidable Deaths

An NHS whistleblower wrote to John Swinney three times before going public with details of multiple avoidable deaths at a major Scottish hospital.
Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, wrote to then-first minister Humza Yousaf in 2023 before sending a further three letters to John Swinney in October 2024, November 2025, and May of this year. Speaking at a press conference in Glasgow, Dr Habib claimed that hundreds of patients may have suffered “significant harm or avoidable deaths” in recent years.

Dr Habib shared the findings of a review instructed by NHS Grampian in September 2022. The evaluation examined 45 liver and pancreatic surgery cases and found that 19 deaths were avoidable among the 31 patients who died between 2015 and 2021.
The whistleblower’s disclosures were raised by opposition parties during First Minister’s Questions. Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra stated that the revelations followed reports of children put at risk by NHS Grampian, adding that at least 19 individuals died at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary in avoidable circumstances.

“Dr Habib, a consultant at NHS Grampian, has today put his career on the line in a desperate pursuit of change, and so those who knew what was happening can be held accountable,” Marra said. He called for the Permanent Secretary to commission an urgent internal review into who within the Scottish Government knew about the correspondence, and urged the Lord Advocate to move toward a criminal prosecution.
Marra added: “Families were not told, the public were not told, but the First Minister was told. Four times Dr Habib wrote to Scottish ministers — including three times to John Swinney — seeking help for the people in his care. Yet, nothing was done to stop the deaths.”
Responding to reporters after First Minister’s Questions, Swinney stated that he had not seen any of the correspondence from the senior medic until earlier that day.
“The letters from Dr Habib were handled within the Government’s system. Because they related to clinical concerns, they were handled by Government officials, making sure those issues were all pursued by all the relevant authorities,” Swinney said. “I saw the letters today for the first time. The normal practices have been followed whereby expressions of concern about clinical practice are addressed by the relevant bodies, which can act upon those areas of concern.”