Politics

Justice Department Secures Massive Payouts for Trump-Connected Plaintiffs

Top Trump administration officials intervened to secure half-million-dollar payouts for five plaintiffs in a federal class-action lawsuit, including a long-serving golf professional at a Trump-owned property. The settlement, which totaled $2.5 million, stems from a suit alleging the IRS failed to protect taxpayer information from a data breach by a government contractor.

Under federal law, victims of unauthorized tax data disclosure are typically entitled to $1,000 per violation. The $500,000 individual payouts represent a figure 250 times higher than the statutory amount. Legal experts and sources familiar with the matter noted that such settlements are exceptionally rare absent evidence of actual damages, and the deal bypassed standard consultations with IRS Office of Chief Counsel attorneys.

image

Gil Rothenberg, a former head of the Justice Department tax division’s appellate section, stated the arrangement “is not passing the smell test.” He noted that the unusual size of the settlement, combined with the fact that it occurred before a district court ruling, effectively bars the government from further appeals.

The underlying case, *Safe Harbor International LLC v. Booz Allen Hamilton*, alleges that the IRS and contractor Booz Allen Hamilton were negligent in allowing employee Charles Littlejohn to leak confidential tax records. Littlejohn was sentenced to five years in prison in 2023 after pleading guilty to the unauthorized disclosure of tax information, which included data on thousands of high-net-worth individuals.

image

The plaintiffs in the settlement include Shelby Lowman, a golf pro at Trump National Golf Club Hudson Valley who has worked at the club for 17 years and is known for painting scenes of Trump properties. Other plaintiffs include the firm Safe Harbor International, which counts Donald Wilson—an investor in the president’s media company, Trump Media and Technology Group—among its investors. A spokesperson for Wilson stated he was unaware of the lawsuit and had no involvement in settlement discussions.

Documents and sources indicate the settlement offer was presented by two Trump political appointees, Brett Shumate and Joshua Wu, rather than the career DOJ trial attorney typically assigned to the case. Critics have voiced concerns that the payout could serve as a model for broader liability, as the plaintiffs claim the potential class size reaches into the hundreds of thousands. Such a scale, if applied broadly, could result in federal government liabilities reaching into the billions.

A White House spokesperson said the Justice Department is “promoting efficient resolution of cases to avoid extraordinary liability.” Spokespeople for the Justice Department and the IRS declined to comment on the pending case.

The lawsuit remains active despite the settlement. Two additional individuals have stepped forward to continue the litigation, both of whom have documented connections to Trump businesses. One is a former lifeguard at a Westchester County Trump golf club, and the other is a retired accountant who previously worked at the same Hudson Valley property as Lowman. A judge has not yet ruled on whether the case may proceed with these new plaintiffs.

Isabella Brooks

Isabella Brooks writes about elections, public policy, political leadership, and government decisions. Her work explores competing viewpoints and explains the impact of political developments on citizens, institutions, and international relations.
Back to top button