Former Officials Criticize Commerce Department Enforcement Under Lutnick

Former Commerce Department officials are describing Secretary Howard Lutnick’s tenure as being marked by chaos, micromanaging, and what they allege are failures to act on evidence of advanced computer chip smuggling to adversaries like China. Investigating and enforcing export bans on sophisticated artificial intelligence chips and hardware represents a primary national security responsibility for the department. According to former staff members who spoke anonymously out of fear of professional reprisals, the agency experienced an inexplicable refusal to utilize available national security tools over the past year.
Scrutiny surrounding Lutnick’s administration has intensified following Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s resignation after he admitted to an affair with a woman U.S. intelligence agencies identified as a suspected Chinese spy. China has denied the spying allegations, characterizing them as an attempt to smear the country. As the scandal developed, lawmakers and senior officials questioned how Nvidia was permitted to sell chips to companies possessing deep ties to China and whether the Commerce Department effectively policed those exports. Former staff stated that the department offered no enforcement at all.
One former employee reported a complete halt in adding entities to the federal Entity List, which bans specific foreign firms from acquiring advanced chips due to diversion risks to adversaries. Another former official noted that a full year passed without any companies added to the list, marking the first such gap in 18 years. Federal Register records show the last additions occurred on Oct. 9, 2025, and the previous yearlong gap took place in 2008. Furthermore, an initial former staffer alleged that Commerce directors took no action after the agency’s enforcement officers identified suspicious activity at Southeast Asian sites receiving Nvidia deliveries.
The Biden administration previously issued AI chip export controls in 2022 and 2023, followed by an interim final rule in January 2025 designed to block adversaries from acquiring advanced processors. In May 2025, President Trump’s Commerce Department rolled back that rule, contending it would stifle American innovation, and stated it would instead issue industry guidance to strengthen controls. Multiple reports indicate those bans have been heavily circumvented. An April 2026 study by AI research nonprofit Epoch estimated that between 290,000 and 1.6 million cutting-edge AI chips were smuggled into China during 2024 and 2025. Additionally, tech news outlet The Information reported that at least $7.5 billion in Nvidia chips allegedly reached Chinese companies via networks linked to Alice Huang, and a former OpenAI researcher published a paper last week presenting digital forensic evidence that restricted Nvidia chips were used to train top Chinese AI models.

Former personnel described the department under Lutnick as frantic and chaotic, with employees occasionally learning of significant policy shifts through news reports. One former staff member stated they discovered a pivot allowing sales of Nvidia’s H20 and H200 chips to China through , adding that the decision appeared to be made between President Trump and Jensen Huang. Neither the Commerce Department nor the White House responded to requests for comment.
On Monday, the department enacted a new rule requiring export, re-export, or transfer licenses for advanced semiconductors destined for Brazil, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, or Thailand to close intermediary loopholes. However, the agency suggested its own role was limited, stating the rule was written by and directed by the Department of Treasury and the National Security Council to address remote access to advanced super intelligence chips and servers.
The agency also experienced high-level departures shortly after Lutnick took office in February 2025, when first reported the exits of Matthew Borman, principal deputy assistant secretary for export administration who served for over three decades, and Eileen Albanese, longtime director of the Office of National Security Controls. Former employees stated those exits initiated an exodus of up to 50 skilled staff members over an 18-month period, draining institutional memory. Bureau of Industry and Security records indicate several key senior roles, including the principal deputy assistant secretary for export administration, export enforcement, and chief of staff positions, remain vacant.
Staff members also pointed to bottlenecks involving Jeffrey Kessler, a top deputy to Lutnick who headed the Bureau of Industry and Security, accusing him of micromanaging and blocking enforcement actions. A former employee said Kessler required every minor decision to be packaged into memos with options for a decision maker. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent added to the criticism in a CNBC interview last week, stating that Lutnick failed to execute chip ban enforcement supported by the Treasury, State Department, and others in the administration.