World News

COP31 Climate Talks Attract Record Crowds Despite Modest Negotiation Outlook

There is a distinct paradox at the center of this year’s United Nations climate conference in Antalya, Turkey. While the event is larger than ever—with tens of thousands of lanyard-wearing participants streaming in every morning, grabbing free apples and chocolate at the entrance, and packing every corridor of a gargantuan expo center—the expected end result remains modest, if not marginal.

George Hussey, an Irish attendee and member of Ireland’s Climate Change Advisory Council, surveyed the crowds this week amid the echo of competing climate panels and posed a common question: “What is all this for?”

Decades ago, the work to address climate change consisted of smallish, technical affairs. Over time, however, the conferences have boomed into trade shows and networking events, offering opportunities to lobby, brainstorm, and commiserate. This year’s 12-day conference, known as COP31, marks the apparent completion of that transformation. Only about 20 percent of the record 92,000 registered participants are there for the formal negotiations.

Many attendees wonder whether the crowds are excessive or whether they demonstrate climate change’s salience even as it appeared to have slipped as a priority in a world focused on conflicts, artificial intelligence, and economic problems. Either way, an event often judged by a single formal outcome now consists of thousands of outcomes, as specific as the people in attendance.

image

“Everybody has their own piece of the puzzle here that they’re interested in,” Mr. Hussey said.

This year’s participants include environmental insurance experts, American law students, advocates for sustainable aviation fuels, and one man wearing a Santa hat identifying as SustainaClaus. Some attendees came for an “Olympics” focused on building energy savings.

Daniel Cusworth, an American scientist at Carbon Mapper, pitched tools to governments to uncover large sources of methane, a powerful greenhouse gas. Carlos Garcia, a Mexican filmmaker, screened a short documentary on landfills, rendered vividly enough for viewers to see flies through 3-D glasses. Meanwhile, Bashiir Mohamed, the leader of a Somali green energy association, came to rally funding so that 100,000 homes could obtain solar panels and gain the ability to power phones, refrigerators, and air-conditioning units.

“Energy changes everything,” Mr. Mohamed said.

image

Sentiments that the annual climate conference has grown beyond its purpose are widespread. The event’s carbon footprint has increased 25-fold over three decades. Two years ago, 22 environmental leaders and scientists wrote a letter to the United Nations calling for the event to be streamlined through “smaller, more frequent, solution-driven meetings.”

However, Johan Rockström, a Swedish scientist who signed that letter, said he has experienced second thoughts. The large gatherings “manifest to the world that this is something to take seriously,” he said, adding that they hold deep meaning for participants who spend nearly two weeks working long hours in what can feel like “planetary-scale therapy sessions.”

His primary reservation is that the good feeling might be unearned. “We are still able to tell ourselves that we have done everything we can,” said Dr. Rockström, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research in Germany. “Is this a way for the climate community to feel less frustrated?”

Advocates for the U.N. process point out that it has achieved notable progress. Global temperatures were once projected to rise almost 4 degrees Celsius, or 7.2 degrees Fahrenheit, above preindustrial levels. Due to nations’ commitments under the 2015 Paris climate agreement and the spread of renewable energy, warming is now on track for 2.8 degrees Celsius, or 5 degrees Fahrenheit, if current policies continue.

image

Over the years, organizers have established and enlarged an agenda outside formal negotiations to encompass voluntary measures from nations, cities, businesses, and investors. Whereas formal negotiations used to be the centerpiece, now “it’s just a little dot in the middle,” said Bill Hare, chief executive of Climate Analytics, a Berlin-based climate science and policy institute.

At COP31, negotiators are again fighting over references to fossil fuels in a final agreement, with oil-producing countries capable of blocking any deal within the consensus-based process. On the sidelines, however, dozens of events have been devoted to transitioning away from coal, oil, and gas, and a handful of nations have announced new domestic pledges.

Those hints of momentum, combined with the experience of gathering among like-minded individuals, “makes COP really fulfilling, even if on a bigger level it’s a pretty dire situation we’re facing,” said Natalie Jones, a senior policy adviser at the International Institute for Sustainable Development, an independent research organization.

Several factors contributed to the immense size of this year’s COP. Turkey serves as a convenient destination from Europe, Asia, and Africa, and Antalya offers an ample supply of hotel rooms. Additionally, Turkey padded the participant list with 14,000 guests, including civil servants, academics, and politicians. Consequently, COP31 is more than twice the size of last year’s event, which was held in a Brazilian city on the edge of the rainforest where organizers relied on cruise ships to ease hotel shortages.

image

Event conditions have remained near-ideal, particularly after Turkey resolved initial transportation challenges during the opening days. Daily temperatures have hovered around 70 degrees. The expo venue features local artisans drawing calligraphy and whittling wooden spinning tops, a domed food court with speakers playing fake birdsong, and an ornamental water channel zigzagging around coffee shops—into which one participant inevitably fell.

“The venue is great,” said Gerald Miles, an Australian conservationist and longtime COP attendee who was fine-tuning a speech near a pagoda. Among the highlights, he noted, were “the apples and chocolate.”

Mr. Hussey compared attending COP to “being back in school,” noting that everywhere he looked, there was something new to learn. As he spoke, one of Ireland’s former presidents walked by, followed by the country’s climate and energy minister.

“Unfortunately, no matter how long you stay here, you can only tap a little,” Mr. Hussey concluded. “You wouldn’t want to live your life in this weird place. It’s not natural. But a little bit every year. You realize, we’re not on our own here.”

Sophia Mitchell

Sophia Mitchell reports on international affairs, global developments, and major events across regions. She brings readers reliable updates and useful context on the people, decisions, and challenges shaping an interconnected world.
Back to top button