ASEAN and China Fail to Finalize South China Sea Code

Negotiations between the Association of Southeast Asian Nations and China failed to conclude a long-delayed South China Sea code of conduct during the Philippines’ chairmanship, officials announced on Sunday. Despite achieving provisional agreement on approximately 80% of the draft text, deep divisions and key unresolved issues ultimately stalled the effort.
Talks regarding an ASEAN-China Code of Conduct in the South China Sea have persisted for more than two decades. The Philippines, serving as the current chair of the 11-member bloc, had previously committed to accelerating discussions and finalizing the code this year.
“There is no conclusion yet,” Philippine Foreign Minister Ma. Theresa Lazaro stated during a press conference at the ASEAN summit in Manila on Sunday. Lazaro noted that several pivotal issues remain unsettled, including whether the eventual code will be legally binding, and added that the participating nations hold differing perspectives on how matters should be handled.

Southeast Asian neighbors of China have consistently pressed for the code to be anchored in international law. These nations have repeatedly accused Beijing of ignoring international legal standards while asserting sovereignty over nearly all of the South China Sea. Conversely, Beijing maintains that its maritime activities are lawful and professional.
China’s extensive claims overlap with the exclusive economic zones of several ASEAN members, including Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Vietnam, creating a pressing need for a functional regulatory framework to prevent escalation and manage maritime incidents. An international arbitration tribunal determined in 2016 that China’s sweeping territorial claims lack any legal basis under international law—a ruling that Beijing continues to reject. In recent years, Manila and Beijing have experienced numerous maritime confrontations, with the Philippines accusing China of aggressive tactics within its exclusive economic zone, such as dangerous maneuvers, water-cannoning, and interference with resupply missions. Meanwhile, Beijing has accused the Philippines of intruding into Chinese-claimed territory.
External analysts point out that obstacles to the agreement extend beyond differences between ASEAN and Beijing. Collin Koh, a senior fellow at Singapore’s S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, observed that internal divergences among ASEAN member states, including disagreements regarding the geographical scope of the code, have also hindered progress. Koh stated that the remaining differences will prove difficult to resolve and necessitate significant concessions from all involved parties.
Singapore is set to inherit the responsibility of pursuing an agreement on the code of conduct when it assumes the ASEAN chairmanship next year.