Politics

Appeals Court Strikes Down Pregnant Workers Fairness Act Over Quorum Clause

The New Orleans-based 5th Circuit Court of Appeals issued a 9-8 decision on Friday that strikes down the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, declaring the federal law unconstitutional due to the process by which it was passed.

The court determined that Congress violated the U.S. Constitution when it approved the law as part of a $1.7 trillion spending package in December 2022. At the time of the vote, the U.S. House of Representatives was operating under COVID-19 pandemic-era rules that allowed members to cast votes by proxy. The majority of the 5th Circuit judges ruled that because a quorum of members was not physically present during the vote, the legislative process was invalid.

In its decision, the court cited historical precedent and the text of the Quorum Clause, asserting that members of Congress must be physically present for quorum purposes, a standard supported by Supreme Court rulings dating back over 125 years. “‘Proxy presence’ does not count,” the court stated.

The ruling effectively invalidates the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi, the states covered by the 5th Circuit. Advocates for the law expressed concerns that the decision could imperil the legislation nationwide.

A Better Balance, the advocacy group that spearheaded the law’s passage, issued a statement on Friday criticizing the ruling as “legally unsound and short-sighted.” Inimai Chettiar, the group’s president, warned that the decision threatens the “health, livelihoods, and economic security of millions of American women and their families.” The organization stated it intends to appeal the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court.

The legal challenge originated in 2023 when Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sued to block the act, arguing it was unconstitutional. A federal judge initially agreed with Paxton in 2024, blocking enforcement of the law for state employees in Texas. A three-judge panel on the 5th Circuit later disagreed in 2025, finding that the law was properly passed under the House’s pandemic rules, but the full 5th Circuit court has now reversed that position.

In their dissent, the eight judges who would have upheld the law noted that no member of Congress objected to the lack of a quorum when the spending bill was passed. The dissenting judges also highlighted a perceived inconsistency in the state’s position, writing, “The State of Texas, having accepted the vast majority of the funds that Congress appropriated to it, now contends that the portion of the bill providing protections for pregnant women and workers violates the Quorum Clause.”

While the law was passed during the Biden administration, the Department of Justice under the Trump administration has continued to oppose Paxton’s lawsuit. Legal analysts suggest the outcome of this case could establish a precedent with implications for other pandemic-era legislation passed via proxy voting.

What's your take on this story? Share your perspective below.Join in

Join the discussion

0

Isabella Brooks

Isabella Brooks writes about elections, public policy, political leadership, and government decisions. Her work explores competing viewpoints and explains the impact of political developments on citizens, institutions, and international relations.
Back to top button