Business

Small-Business Owner Challenges Funding Firm in High-Stakes Fraud Lawsuit

Vahe Shahinian, a small-business owner based in Glendale, California, has spent seven years in a persistent legal struggle against a merchant cash advance (MCA) provider, alleging that the firm engaged in fraud and predatory practices that devastated his finances. The case, currently unfolding in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles, challenges the business practices of EIN Cap, a New York-based firm, and serves as a rare example of a borrower pursuing litigation against an industry often characterized by its lack of regulatory oversight.

Shahinian’s conflict began in 2019 when he sought stable funding to support his company, It’s My Seat, a platform that sold tickets and produced concerts. At the time, his business was expanding into tour production, a capital-intensive endeavor. Shahinian alleges that a broker misled him regarding a $750,000 line of credit, presenting the deal as a routine financial arrangement that required a 30-day testing period of daily payments. However, according to Shahinian, the promised line of credit never materialized, and the arrangement shifted into a series of costly merchant cash advances.

The industry for merchant cash advances typically functions by providing upfront capital in exchange for a portion of a business’s future sales. Because these transactions are technically classified as purchases of future earnings rather than traditional loans, they are often exempt from many of the lending laws and interest rate caps that apply to standard banking products. Fees for such advances can translate into effective annual interest rates ranging from 25% to 200%. As the industry has grown, critics have raised concerns about “carroting,” a practice where borrowers are lured with the prospect of affordable financing, only to be steered into unsolicited and expensive cash advances.

Shane Heskin, an attorney representing Shahinian, notes that this bait-and-switch tactic is becoming increasingly common, particularly among first-time business owners and immigrants. Shahinian, a former aerospace engineer who had self-funded his business for 15 years without missing a payment, found himself in a spiral of debt after the initial agreement. He says he was required to pay daily installments of $3,600, which rapidly drained his operational cash flow. As his debt mounted, Shahinian took out additional cash advances to stay afloat, eventually losing his home to foreclosure and accruing more than $1 million in debt to friends and family.

In his lawsuit, Shahinian accuses EIN Cap of fraud. The firm has denied the allegations in public court filings. Levi Silver, counsel for EIN, declined to comment further on the matter, citing the pending status of the case. Court records indicate that much of the documentation regarding the firm’s relationship with the brokers involved in the transaction has been sealed. The trial has faced multiple delays, leaving the legal dispute unresolved.

Shahinian’s legal pursuit has required significant personal effort, including hiring a private investigator to serve the lawsuit and researching similar cases to support his claims. His investigation revealed that the broker who introduced him to the funding deal, identified in court documents as Boris Shteyngart, had a prior conviction for grand larceny. While EIN Cap has faced various lawsuits across multiple states—most related to borrower bankruptcies—many have been settled or dismissed. In a recent Illinois case, a federal judge ordered EIN Cap to return profits, concluding that the firm had “propped up” and “prolonged” a business that was operating a scheme.

Despite the financial and personal toll, including moving back into his childhood home, Shahinian continues to pursue the case. Recent legislative developments in California have signaled a shift in the regulatory environment; a new state law set to take effect in 2028 will require funders and brokers to undergo licensing, background checks, and inspections. For Shahinian, however, the focus remains on his ongoing litigation, which he hopes will not only provide restitution but also serve as a signal for the industry to self-correct and offer hope to other business owners in similar positions.

What's your take on this story? Share your perspective below.Join in

Join the discussion

0

Mia Reynolds

Mia Reynolds covers companies, entrepreneurship, leadership, and changing industries. She turns complex business developments into accessible stories, helping readers follow corporate decisions, market shifts, and trends influencing the global business landscape.
Back to top button