Federal Housing Policies Face New Scrutiny Amid Homelessness Reforms

Recent efforts to reform homelessness policy at the federal level have drawn attention to the escalating costs and shifting strategies used to address the crisis in major cities. A central point of contention involves the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development’s (HUD) decision to move away from established models in favor of initiatives that prioritize employment and accountability.
Paul Webster, a former senior policy advisor for HUD and current senior fellow at the Cicero Institute, argues that current policies often result in a double burden for taxpayers: initial funding for programs that frequently fail, followed by the secondary costs of addressing public safety issues.
“I have a friend who has owned a couple of warehouses just west of Skid Row in downtown Los Angeles. He can’t get tenants for them,” Webster said. Describing the environment, he noted that streets are often occupied by non-operational recreational vehicles, which he alleges are sometimes rented by criminal entities to the homeless. Because these vehicles are classified as residences in Los Angeles, they cannot be towed, complicating attempts to manage encampment areas.
“Rent is not always money,” Webster said. “Rent could be holding drugs. Rent could be distributing drugs. The rent could be engaging in prostitution. The rent could be stealing or shoplifting. So there’s there’s all kinds of ways that rent is paid amongst homeless encampments in Los Angeles.”
In Los Angeles, the fiscal and operational impact of these policies has come under federal scrutiny. HUD recently defunded the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority (LAHSA) after the Office of Inspector General uncovered evidence of fraud and mismanagement. The move was part of a settlement resolving litigation regarding the funding suspension. According to HUD, homelessness funding in the city increased by 178% since the adoption of a “housing first” model in 2013, yet the homeless population doubled during the same period.
“Under President Trump, HUD is standing up for every taxpayer’s hard-earned money and cutting off fraud-filled LAHSA, LA’s lead agency for homeless response,” a HUD spokesperson said. The department expects to recover $150 million.
The federal push toward reforms is rooted in concerns about cost-effectiveness. The U.S. Interagency Council on Homelessness estimates that a person who is chronically homeless incurs between $30,000 and $50,000 in taxpayer costs annually. Data from the National Alliance to End Homelessness provides a similar estimate of $35,578.
A report published in August by the Cicero Institute analyzed the Continuum of Care Program, the primary federal grant program for homelessness. The findings indicated that as of 2023, a median of 6% of participants increased their earned employment income, compared to 33% who increased their reliance on benefits and welfare. The report concluded that many programs have placed excessive burdens on public budgets without delivering significant employment gains.
However, some advocates argue that the focus should remain on permanent supportive housing. Ann Oliva, CEO of the National Alliance to End Homelessness, stated that studies continue to support the effectiveness of this model. “Reducing homelessness improves all of our lives. There are many studies that show that Permanent Supportive Housing reduces the need for emergency services,” Oliva said. “This reduces costs for hospitals, emergency rooms, and police departments, and enables them to better serve the public.”
Recent governmental shifts are not limited to federal mandates. In San Francisco, Mayor Daniel Lurie has implemented accountability-focused reforms similar to those pursued at the federal level. “We are not going to continue spending $1 billion of taxpayer money on a failing system—we’re fixing the system so we can deliver the safe and clean streets every San Franciscan deserves,” Lurie said in August.
According to data released by HUD on Nov. 6, homelessness decreased by 6.3% since President Donald Trump took office in 2025. This follows the broader trends detailed in the Annual Homelessness Assessment Report from May, which noted a 27% increase in homelessness since 2013, though it also showed a 3% decline compared to 2024. Despite these shifts, significant increases in chronic homelessness—up 81% from 2013 to 2025—remain a challenge for policymakers.
Neither the California Housing and Homelessness Agency nor the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority provided a response to inquiries regarding these developments.