Scottish Aid Workers Warn of Humanitarian Catastrophe in Ukraine

Two aid workers from Scotland report on the severe conditions facing civilians in Kharkiv as Ukraine prepares for a winter threatened by destroyed energy infrastructure.
Two Scottish aid workers from the charity Edinburgh Direct Aid International have warned of a potential humanitarian catastrophe in Ukraine this winter, following their return from the war-torn country. Maggie Tookey and Clea Friend, who spent several weeks operating in Kharkiv, reported that the ongoing conflict has left the nation’s energy infrastructure devastated, raising fears that civilians will face extreme winter temperatures without access to power, heating, water, or sewage.
Temperatures in the region can drop as low as -17C. According to Tookey, who has frequently delivered aid since the invasion began in February 2022, the situation facing the population is dire. “Last winter, they had spasmodic switch-ons for power and heating but this winter that may not happen and they find themselves with no relief in January and February,” she said. “It’s looking very grim and I have no faith in peace talks.”
Tookey noted that the persistent destruction has had a significant mental toll on the population, stating that the team she worked with in Ukraine relies on anxiety medication. The conflict, now nearing its fifth year, remains a grinding attritional battle along the eastern frontier.
Friend described the normalized atmosphere of danger in Kharkiv, where air raid sirens sounded throughout the day. “You become numb to it,” she said. “When we were in Kharkiv, the sirens were on all day long, and we were just walking about in the park. Everybody’s just going about their business. You become deaf to it in a way. That’s how people resist, that’s their way of just carrying on because otherwise, what are they going to do?”
During their time in the region, the pair worked to deliver supplies, including tourniquets to villagers. Tookey described a training mission in a village near the front line, where they instructed women on how to stop bleeding from shrapnel wounds. She noted that some of the villagers had already successfully used the training to save lives after subsequent attacks. The threat of drone warfare is constant; Tookey recounted one instance near Prudyanka where a truck was struck shortly before their arrival. She observed that the village, which she previously knew well, had been devastated, with its population falling from nearly 400 to 40, primarily elderly, disabled individuals, or young people acting as caregivers.
Friend described the experience of driving toward remote villages in an old ambulance as being “like being in a computer game.” She noted that roads out of Kharkiv are covered with netting to mitigate drone strikes, a protection that ends once vehicles travel into more remote, dangerous areas.
Beyond the immediate physical dangers, the aid workers highlighted the exhaustion of Ukrainian forces, contrasting it with the perceived optimism they encountered during previous visits in 2023. Meanwhile, the broader political and military situation remains tense. President Volodymyr Zelensky has alleged that speed restrictions on the Starlink satellite system, operated by Elon Musk’s SpaceX, have hindered Ukraine’s ability to intercept incoming Russian drones and missiles. These developments coincide with ongoing friction between Zelensky and U.S. President Donald Trump, who has pushed for an end to the war on terms favorable to the Kremlin while threatening to curtail military assistance.
Edinburgh Direct Aid International continues its work by funding sensory rooms for children suffering from trauma and supporting music therapy programs. The charity has also focused on converting basements into “safe schools” to maintain education despite the widespread disruption caused by the invasion.