Charges Dropped Against Driver in Death of Florida Grandmother

Prosecutors dismissed all charges against the driver involved in a fatal parking lot collision that killed an 82-year-old woman in Panama City.
Prosecutors have dropped all charges against a Venezuelan national accused of fatally striking an 82-year-old woman in a Panama City Beach grocery store parking lot earlier this year.
Deborah Murphy was killed on May 17, 2026, while carrying a grocery bag across a crosswalk at a local Publix. Surveillance video captured the incident, showing Murphy walking toward her vehicle before being struck by a Toyota 4Runner backing up. The vehicle, driven by 26-year-old Carlos Suarez-Contreras, continued moving after the initial impact, according to an arrest affidavit filed by the Florida Highway Patrol.
Larry Basford, state attorney for Florida’s Fourteenth Judicial Circuit, stated that his office spent nearly six months attempting to build a criminal case, but ultimately determined that Florida law posed significant obstacles to a successful prosecution.
“I think everyone would agree that what he did was careless and it was negligent,” Basford said. However, he noted that the state could not establish the “culpable negligence” required for charges such as vehicular homicide or manslaughter. Prosecutors conducted a re-enactment of the fatal event using the surveillance footage and determined the vehicle was not traveling at a speed sufficient to prove reckless driving.
Additionally, the prosecution faced challenges regarding the driver’s licensing status. Suarez-Contreras was operating the vehicle with a canceled Georgia driver’s license. However, the license had been canceled only one day prior to the collision. Basford explained that to secure a conviction related to the license, prosecutors would have to prove the defendant was aware it was suspended, which they could not establish.
Legislative limitations also factored into the case. Prosecutors examined a 2023 Florida law that invalidates driver’s licenses issued to illegal immigrants in certain other states. Basford noted that the legislation does not include Georgia in the list of states where licenses are invalidated under that statute.
Murphy’s daughter, Amy Edge, expressed deep frustration with the outcome, stating that the family feels “incredibly let down” by the state. Edge and her twin sister, Beth Schulz, criticized the thoroughness of the investigation, questioning why certain measures, such as drug or alcohol testing and a review of the driver’s phone records, were not pursued.
“We know the man killed her,” Edge said. “He never got out of the car. He never ran to her aid.”
Following the dismissal of the charges, Suarez-Contreras was transferred into the custody of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) on November 15. Edge indicated that the family finds some comfort in his detainment and potential deportation, though they plan to continue advocating for changes to Florida law or investigative procedures to prevent similar tragedies.
“There’s a lot of different questions we have that we’ll continue to explore, but not in a vengeful way,” Edge said. “It’s more in that we don’t want this to happen to someone else.”